Self and Other: Exploring Subjectivity, Empathy, and Shame

Self and Other: Exploring Subjectivity, Empathy, and Shame

  • Downloads:8119
  • Type:Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
  • Create Date:2021-04-03 14:55:56
  • Update Date:2025-09-06
  • Status:finish
  • Author:Dan Zahavi
  • ISBN:0198776675
  • Environment:PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle

Summary

Can you be a self on your own or only together with others? Is selfhood a built-in feature of experience or rather socially constructed? How do we at all come to understand others? Does empathy amount to and allow for a distinct experiential acquaintance with others, and if so, what does that tell us about the nature of selfhood and social cognition? Does a strong emphasis on the first-personal character of consciousness prohibit a satisfactory account of intersubjectivity or is the former rather a necessary requirement for the latter?

Engaging with debates and findings in classical phenomenology, in philosophy of mind and in various empirical disciplines, Dan Zahavi's new book Self and Other offers answers to these questions。 Discussing such diverse topics as self-consciousness, phenomenal externalism, mindless coping, mirror self-recognition, autism, theory of mind, embodied simulation, joint attention, shame, time-consciousness, embodiment, narrativity, self-disorders, expressivity and Buddhist no-self accounts, Zahavi argues that any theory of consciousness that wishes to take the subjective dimension of our experiential life serious must endorse a minimalist notion of self。 At the same time, however, he also contends that an adequate account of the self has to recognize its multifaceted character, and that various complementary accounts must be integrated, if we are to do justice to its complexity。 Thus, while arguing that the most fundamental level of selfhood is not socially constructed and not constitutively dependent upon others, Zahavi also acknowledges that there are dimensions of the self and types of self-experience that are other-mediated。 The final part of the book exemplifies this claim through a close analysis of shame。

Download

Reviews

Jing

What distinguishes human being from animals? A leading candidate is our consciousness of self。 In the last several decades, this idea has moved from folk conjecture to serious philosophical theory。 This book by Dan Zahavi, contributes his over twenty years ongoing endeavor on the topics of self and other。 The consistent themes throughout the book are the multidimension account of the self and a non-reductive understanding of the relation of self and other。 By drawing upon the early contribution What distinguishes human being from animals? A leading candidate is our consciousness of self。 In the last several decades, this idea has moved from folk conjecture to serious philosophical theory。 This book by Dan Zahavi, contributes his over twenty years ongoing endeavor on the topics of self and other。 The consistent themes throughout the book are the multidimension account of the self and a non-reductive understanding of the relation of self and other。 By drawing upon the early contributions of early phenomenologists, Zahavi’s offers a middle path between Cartesian self-sufficient self and entirely socially mediated self。 The primitive form of self, which he calls the minimal or experiential self, is given as part of the structure of conscious experience, well before any self-consciousness appropriation takes place。 Zahavi’s later interpretation of intersubjectivity feeds back into his multifaceted account of self。 Looking at the phenomena of empathy and shame, Zahavi maps out various states of self-consciousness which require a more complex other-mediated form of self。 In closing, Zahavi explores the structure of the we。 According to him, the prime point of a we s that of “second-person singular”。 The scope of the book is enormous, well-written and extremely clear in exposition。 Zahavi not only provides an overview of the state of self and other in both phenomenological and analytical tradition, presents an important and original position, but also dives into this terrain with a theory that brings coherence and unity to the recent findings in empirical investigation。 The Japanese translation of this book is out and its Chinese translation is in processing。 。。。more

Tijmen Lansdaal

The expertise of Zahavi is incredibly impressive, and so is his ability to elucidate experiences such that they are more easily distinguished conceptually。 However, oddly enough, I don't think this book will be satisfactory for anyone。 For critics, they will probably never find the minimal notion of self to be substantial enough to be acceptable as a distinct concept of selfhood (I've heard someone argue that Zahavi's mineness sounds very much like the phenomenological codicil of Meillassoux - a The expertise of Zahavi is incredibly impressive, and so is his ability to elucidate experiences such that they are more easily distinguished conceptually。 However, oddly enough, I don't think this book will be satisfactory for anyone。 For critics, they will probably never find the minimal notion of self to be substantial enough to be acceptable as a distinct concept of selfhood (I've heard someone argue that Zahavi's mineness sounds very much like the phenomenological codicil of Meillassoux - a concept I btw think is utterly ridiculous)。 For me, someone who is largely very enthusiastic about Husserl, this minimal notion of self is never really cashed out in terms of intentional or transcendental structures。 He seems to want to avoid classical notions and he seems to end up hollowing out most of his own ambitions。 Surely he's settled that the debate on how socially determined conscious activity is filled with confusing notions of self, and that it really helps to differentiate in kinds of social experiences。 However, as long as this notion of self is so incredibly non-committal ('thin'), he'll probably face ever more obscure counterarguments against it from the no-self and/or social theorists。 。。。more