Beren y Lúthien
- Downloads：5649
- Type：Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
- Create Date：2022-09-04 01:52:07
- Update Date：2025-09-06
- Status：finish
- Author：J.R.R. Tolkien
- ISBN：8445005065
- Environment：PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle
- Download
Summary
El relato de Beren y Lúthien era， o se convirtió， en un elemento esencial en la evolución de El Silmarillion， los mitos y leyendas de la Primera Edad del Mundo concebidos por J。 R。 R。 Tolkien。 El autor escribió el relato durante el año siguiente a su regreso de Francia y de la batalla del Somme a finales de 1916。
Esencial para la historia y sin haber sido nunca alterado， el elemento central del relato es el destino que ensombrece el amor de Beren y Lúthien， dado que Beren era un hombre mortal y Lúthien una Elfa inmortal， cuyo padre， un gran señor Elfo， en clara oposición a Beren， impuso a éste una tarea imposible que debía llevar a cabo si quería desposar a Lúthien。 Éste es el núcleo de la leyenda， que acaba conduciendo al absolutamente heroico intento de Beren y Lúthien de robarle un Silmaril al más malvado de todos los seres: Melkor， también llamado Morgoth， el Enemigo Oscuro。
En este libro Christopher Tolkien ha intentado extraer la historia de Beren y Lúthien del contexto narrativo más amplio al que pertenecía; pero la propia historia había ido cambiando mientras desarrollaba nuevas asociaciones dentro de la mitología。 Para ilustrar una parte del proceso a través del cual este «Gran Relato» de la Tierra Media evolucionó a través de los años， Christopher ha narrado la historia en palabras de su padre ofreciendo， en primer lugar， su forma original， y a continuación pasajes en prosa y verso de textos posteriores。 Presentados en conjunto por vez primera， revelan aspectos argumentales y estilísticos de la historia， que se perdieron más tarde。
Reviews
Steven Shinder
，
I really wanted to enjoy reading this， but the way it's structured and organized hindered that。 We got an introduction by Christopher Tolkien about the backstory regarding his father's making this tale， then we get the tale， and we get variations with comments from Christopher in between， and switching from prose form to poetic form， and not as much dialogue as I would have preferred。 The result is an uneven telling of the evolution of this story， which might be fascinating for people who want t I really wanted to enjoy reading this， but the way it's structured and organized hindered that。 We got an introduction by Christopher Tolkien about the backstory regarding his father's making this tale， then we get the tale， and we get variations with comments from Christopher in between， and switching from prose form to poetic form， and not as much dialogue as I would have preferred。 The result is an uneven telling of the evolution of this story， which might be fascinating for people who want to study that sort of thing， but might feel tedious for one who just wants to experiences a fleshed out and compelling story on its own。 。。。more
Bradford Combs
，
The story of Beren and Luthien is my favorite tale from the Silmarillion， and I was so excited when this novel came out。 I thought it would be like the Chidren of Hurin where the B&L chapter from the Silmarillion would be fleshed out and made into a novel format。 That， unfortunately， wasn't the case。 It was a gathering of different notes and versions compiled together， not meshed into a thorough story。 If you liked The History of Middle Earth， it's more like that。 Just all Beren and Luthien rela The story of Beren and Luthien is my favorite tale from the Silmarillion， and I was so excited when this novel came out。 I thought it would be like the Chidren of Hurin where the B&L chapter from the Silmarillion would be fleshed out and made into a novel format。 That， unfortunately， wasn't the case。 It was a gathering of different notes and versions compiled together， not meshed into a thorough story。 If you liked The History of Middle Earth， it's more like that。 Just all Beren and Luthien related。 It was on okay read， but I got very bored very quickly。 If you'd like to read how Beren and Luthien came about in chronological order of the author's notes， this is for you。 Otherwise， probably best to read something else。 。。。more
Sophie
，
Gostei bastante da história e do jeito que ela foi contada， porque como é uma lenda， ela tem várias versões e o autor fez algumas versões da história， além de ter feito alguns poemas que também retratam a história， o que é bem no estilo medieval dos livros dele
Esteban Ducoing Riojas
，
Beren and Lúthien's story is wonderful， a poetic demonstration of true love （not to mention it's very entertaining）。 This book is much more than just the tale of Beren and Lúthien， it goes deeper into other events from the middle earth。 Tolkien's world is simply immersive。 Beren and Lúthien's story is wonderful， a poetic demonstration of true love （not to mention it's very entertaining）。 This book is much more than just the tale of Beren and Lúthien， it goes deeper into other events from the middle earth。 Tolkien's world is simply immersive。 。。。more
Marcileia
，
Achei cansativo por ter uma boa parte em poesia e repetitivo， já que conta várias versões da história conforme elas foram escritas e modificadas por Tolkieb
Arthur B
，
A more cohesive way of getting to grips with this legend of Middle-Earth than wading through the History of Middle-Earth volumes， but nowhere near as cohesive as The Children of Hurin。 Full review: https://fakegeekboy。wordpress。com/201。。。 A more cohesive way of getting to grips with this legend of Middle-Earth than wading through the History of Middle-Earth volumes， but nowhere near as cohesive as The Children of Hurin。 Full review: https://fakegeekboy。wordpress。com/201。。。 。。。more
Fatemeh Ghazanfari
，
。 داستان برن و لوثین زیباییش رو از عشق تالکین به همسرش میگیره تا حدی که وقتی ادیث تالکین میمیره، جان تالکین تصمیم میگیره روی سنگ قبرش بنویسن لوثین。 کریستوفر تالکین میگه برای چاپ این کتاب دو دلیل دارم。 یکی اینکه داستان برن و لوثین خودش به تنهایی دیده بشه。 دوم اینکه تکامل داستان رو طی سالها نشون بده چون داستان برن و لوثین تو کتابها و جاهای مختلف گفته شده و تو هر کدوم از اینها داستان یه تفاوتهایی داره （از نظر تفاوتهای نژادی برن یا شخصیت پدرش یا اون پلیدی که برن رو به خدمت میگیره یا همرا 。 داستان برن و لوثین زیباییش رو از عشق تالکین به همسرش میگیره تا حدی که وقتی ادیث تالکین میمیره، جان تالکین تصمیم میگیره روی سنگ قبرش بنویسن لوثین。 کریستوفر تالکین میگه برای چاپ این کتاب دو دلیل دارم。 یکی اینکه داستان برن و لوثین خودش به تنهایی دیده بشه。 دوم اینکه تکامل داستان رو طی سالها نشون بده چون داستان برن و لوثین تو کتابها و جاهای مختلف گفته شده و تو هر کدوم از اینها داستان یه تفاوتهایی داره （از نظر تفاوتهای نژادی برن یا شخصیت پدرش یا اون پلیدی که برن رو به خدمت میگیره یا همراهانش در بهدست آوردن سیلماریل و。。。）。 همین طور میگه که سهتا داستان فرزندان هورین، برن و لوثین و سقوط گاندُلین （یا گوندولین） خودشون کافیان و نیازی به اطلاعات سیلماریلیون ندارین پس با خیال راحت و بدون ترس برین سراغشون。 اول کتاب چندین شخصیت و مکان رو با یادآوری داستانهایی از یاران حلقه و دو برج توضیح میده که خب برای کسایی که اونا رو خوندن یه یادآوریِ خیلی。。。。 （حالا که فکر میکنم خیلی مهمی هم نیست） فرق این کتاب با کتاب قبلی （فرزندان هورین） که خوندم در اینه که اونجا کل داستان متن اصلی کتاب رو تشکیل میده و آخرش یه توضیحاتی از کریستوفر تالکین رو پیدا میکنید اما اینجا کریستوفر تالکین اومده مجموعهای از داستانهایی از برن و لوثین تو کتابها و دستنوشتههای مختلف رو جمع کرده و وسطاش توضیح میده این تیکه از کجاست و برای کی فرستاده شده و کِی نوشته شده و فرقش با سایر روایات چیه。 یه فرق دیگهش اینه که توش هم شعر پیدا میکنید هم نثر و یه تنوع جالبی داره （یه چیز دیگه اینکه انتظار این رو نداشته باشید تا داستان رو از اول تا آخر تعریف کنه。 یه جاهایی بر میگرده عقب و به شبهاتی پاسخ میده）。 و خب از اونجایی که کلیّت داستان مدام تکرار میشه اگه علاقهای به خود تالکین نداشته باشین و فقط به امید خوندن داستان اومده باشین تحملش ممکنه سخت باشه。 من انتظار جزئیات داشتم که بود ولی دیگه یه جاهایی میگه it must be short， for it is elsewhere told more fully。پس واضحه که باید برم کتابهای دیگه یعنی the Silmarillion و Unfinished tales رو بخونم。 。。。more
Natia Morbedadze
，
ფენტეზის მოყვარულები მრავალ დიდებულ სამყაროს ვიცნობთ， თუმცა ცალსახაა， რომ მთავარი შემოქმედი ჯონ რონალდ რუელ ტოლკინია。 მან შექმნა საოცარი გმირებით დასახლებული მიწა და მას შუამიწეთი （იგივე შუახმელეთი） უწოდა。 ამ საქმეს მთელი ცხოვრება მიუძღვნა და ის， რაც "ბეჭდების მბრძანებლის" ან "ჰობიტის" მსგავსად ვერ დაასრულა， მისმა ვაჟმა კრისოტფერმა შეკრიბა და ამისთვის მას დიდი მადლობა ეკუთვნის。 მათ შორის ამ წიგნისთვისაც， რომელშიც არა მხოლოდ ბერენისა და ლუთიენის სიყვარულისა და მათ მიერ მორგოთისთვის სილმარილის წარ ფენტეზის მოყვარულები მრავალ დიდებულ სამყაროს ვიცნობთ， თუმცა ცალსახაა， რომ მთავარი შემოქმედი ჯონ რონალდ რუელ ტოლკინია。 მან შექმნა საოცარი გმირებით დასახლებული მიწა და მას შუამიწეთი （იგივე შუახმელეთი） უწოდა。 ამ საქმეს მთელი ცხოვრება მიუძღვნა და ის， რაც "ბეჭდების მბრძანებლის" ან "ჰობიტის" მსგავსად ვერ დაასრულა， მისმა ვაჟმა კრისოტფერმა შეკრიბა და ამისთვის მას დიდი მადლობა ეკუთვნის。 მათ შორის ამ წიგნისთვისაც， რომელშიც არა მხოლოდ ბერენისა და ლუთიენის სიყვარულისა და მათ მიერ მორგოთისთვის სილმარილის წართმევის ისტორიაა მოთხრობილი， არამედ დეტალურადაა აღწერილი მთელი ის გზა， რაც ტოლკინმა წერის პროცესში განვლო。 სწორედ ესაა აქ ყველაზე ღირებული。 。。。more
Connor Daley （CJDsCurrentRead）
，
This one opens with a preface by Christopher， at the age of 93， that I found truly astounding。 It kind of continues throughout the book， as the tale is rather short， and has several versions。 I think that Tolkien fans are really fortunate that he felt himself to be a protector/scholar of his father’s work， rather than living in its shadow， because he’s the only reason a lot of these things saw the light of day。 In this preface he spoke to how his father would often change things， or names， or th This one opens with a preface by Christopher， at the age of 93， that I found truly astounding。 It kind of continues throughout the book， as the tale is rather short， and has several versions。 I think that Tolkien fans are really fortunate that he felt himself to be a protector/scholar of his father’s work， rather than living in its shadow， because he’s the only reason a lot of these things saw the light of day。 In this preface he spoke to how his father would often change things， or names， or themes， and how an addition of a single character or thing could influence him rewriting something entirely。 I loved how Christopher spoke to how he did not take these versions of the great tales to be canon， or to uncanonize other versions， he was just striving to give fans the most linear， narrative story possible。 Beren and Lúthien， or The Tale of Tinúviel （as the story and chapter are entitled—from The Book of Lost Tales Two）， is an extracted version of their love and stealing of a Silmaril from Melkor/Morgoth。 I personally kind of found this edited version to erase Beren， in the sense that it did not really include any background on him and his heroics。 Lúthien runs from her father and even frees Beren， which is in no way an issue for me， but I think it weighs even heavier when you include who he was。 Aka he felt a little useless to me。 Luckily however， this is a rather short extraction。 （And that’s not at all to say that I actually found it to be bad！ At all！！）。 The remainder of the book continues on with additional context from Christopher throughout， as well as additional excerpts from various versions and histories that he’s chosen to highlight for this combined edition of the great tale。 These excerpts are from the actual lay， and therefore are genuine poetry in rhyme。 That’s never been my cup of tea， but you can tell the lyrical prowess that Tolkien had， and the audio most definitely flowed effortlessly。 I once again for my first read through miss out on all the illustrations， but we are hightailing it for The Rings of Power prep。 I of course would be remiss if I did not include the fact that it’s said the story originated from Tolkien taking woodland walks with his wife-to-be Edith， and that he found himself to be the mortal in the presence of greatness， a beauty of the Eldar。 That is why Beren and Lúthien are inscribed on their tombstones， and I can only imagine the story was continually rewrote as their love grew and changed， and Tolkien wove it into the fabric of middle-earth。 。。。more
cobrakai
，
christopher's unnecessary explanations made me sick。 christopher's unnecessary explanations made me sick。 。。。more
annemarie
，
luthien best girl 🫡 that is all
Rover Samwel
，
Beautiful storytelling by Tolkien， and great commentary from Christopher （his son）。 The tale in epic poem form is truly amazing。
Andrii Korpalo
，
Не знав， що очікувати у цій книзі。 Виявилось дослідження про те， як створювалась і змінювалась балада протягом життя Толкіна。
Jennifer Sigman
，
Definitely something I want to own， both for the poetry as for the illustrations。
Matthew Tyrrell-Byrne
，
Whilst I did enjoy this I hadn’t expected the rather scattered structure！My first “middle Earth myth” was the children of Hurin which basically presents as a straight narrative tale （expanded from a version present in the Silmarillion I found out later） and I had expected the same here。Instead we get almost an education and bits of 3-4 versions of the tale with many alterations and alternative passages from the tale of tinuviel to the far expanded verse form the lay of luthien， plus parts of wha Whilst I did enjoy this I hadn’t expected the rather scattered structure！My first “middle Earth myth” was the children of Hurin which basically presents as a straight narrative tale （expanded from a version present in the Silmarillion I found out later） and I had expected the same here。Instead we get almost an education and bits of 3-4 versions of the tale with many alterations and alternative passages from the tale of tinuviel to the far expanded verse form the lay of luthien， plus parts of what ended up usual first age narrative silmarillion style。Still nice to get more info on this fantasy love adventure， the book does show the mammoth task of organising JRRT’s writing！ 。。。more
Mark Redman
，
Beren and Lúthien Is the story of the love and adventures of the mortal man Beren and the immortal Elf maiden Lúthien。 Tolkien wrote several versions of their story the latest version in the Silmarillion。 This book gives us all the different versions together。 I Loved the developments of the different versions of the story having previously enjoyed the Histories of Middle Earth。 I enjoy poetry and the Lay of Leithian is just so beautiful， it shows Tolkien’s mastery of language and emotion is per Beren and Lúthien Is the story of the love and adventures of the mortal man Beren and the immortal Elf maiden Lúthien。 Tolkien wrote several versions of their story the latest version in the Silmarillion。 This book gives us all the different versions together。 I Loved the developments of the different versions of the story having previously enjoyed the Histories of Middle Earth。 I enjoy poetry and the Lay of Leithian is just so beautiful， it shows Tolkien’s mastery of language and emotion is perfect the accompanying art by Alan Lee elevates the whole reading experience。 This will not be for everyone as it can be repetitive at times。 If you’re not a fan of poetry stay clear。 However， if you want to delve deeper into Tolkien’s world， just read this and weep。 。。。more
Lauren
，
middle earth relationship goals！！！ Seriously though， Christopher Tolkien does such a good job compiling his fathers works into one coherent story and making all the complex language of middle earth accesible to readers！！ Reading how the narrative of the story progressed over the years and how the story’s elements evolved was v interesting and I loved being back in middle earth again💚🧝🏻♂️💗🧝🏻♀️⚔️🐺
Stijn Lucieer
，
Op zich wel leuk en interessant， maar erg weinig inhoudelijk verhaal en vooral veel achtergrondinfo
Mariana
，
Thanks gods for the existence of Tolkien in this world
Johannes
，
A beautiful fairytale & an incredibly interesting insight into the creation & evolution of writing & storytelling。 Finally read Tolkien as a poem！One of my favourite J。R。R。 stories so far。😊
Luke Kimery
，
This book was really helpful for understanding the fuller world of Tolkien （though I know that wasn't the point）。 Christopher's short explanation of the major characters and moments in the first age at the beginning if the book was very helpful for me。 Also the list of names at the end is VERY helpful if you ever get confused by the many names of places and people （many of which have multiple names）。 Beyond it just being helpful， the book is fun。 The story of Beren and Luthien has an old english This book was really helpful for understanding the fuller world of Tolkien （though I know that wasn't the point）。 Christopher's short explanation of the major characters and moments in the first age at the beginning if the book was very helpful for me。 Also the list of names at the end is VERY helpful if you ever get confused by the many names of places and people （many of which have multiple names）。 Beyond it just being helpful， the book is fun。 The story of Beren and Luthien has an old english romantic charm， and following it's development through Tolkien's life was interesting， but complicated at times。 It got swept into so many other parts of his life that it almost felt like I needed to know every detail of his life to understand how this myth developed。 Overall， very fun， but kind of a drudge。 。。。more
Liam Carroll
，
This is a difficult book to give a proper rating and review on。 Based off of book descriptions excluding reader reviews， I very reasonably thought I was purchasing a written narrative of the story of Beren and Lúthien。 [Note that I almost never go into reader reviews before reading， simply to avoid spoiling the book]。 I had just finished The Hobbit and then LOTR and their allusion to Beren and Lúthien seemed very interesting。 Had I read reader reviews I would have known what to expect。 And had I This is a difficult book to give a proper rating and review on。 Based off of book descriptions excluding reader reviews， I very reasonably thought I was purchasing a written narrative of the story of Beren and Lúthien。 [Note that I almost never go into reader reviews before reading， simply to avoid spoiling the book]。 I had just finished The Hobbit and then LOTR and their allusion to Beren and Lúthien seemed very interesting。 Had I read reader reviews I would have known what to expect。 And had I known anything about Tolkien’s pieces regarding the story， I could have figured out that it was Christopher stitching together work with deep analysis commentary。 So I do take a large portion of the blame of my disappointment。 But the disappointment is still there。 Now looking at reader reviews it looks like I am not the only one who expected a narrative version of the story。 An actual novel or even novela with Christopher’s added commentary would have been so nice。 And he probably could have written his own fantastic novel himself l， but he won’t dare venture into staining the integrity of his father’s work which I can appreciate。 Do I regret reading it？ No， it was still lovely。 Would I recommend it to anyone？ Only if they were an AGGRESSIVE die hard Tolkien fan （and I mean books not movies） and hadn’t put it on their list。 Even still， I might just recommend reading the Tale of Tinúviel and using the Silmarillion for the rest of the info。 Even if that meant reading the Tale out of their already purchased copy of this book。 I’d just recommend shutting the book once you pass that part。 Decent read。 Not a fav。 。。。more
Gad
，
Tolkien nunca defrauda。 Cada vez que te adentras en uno de sus libros relacionados con la Tierra Media te metes en un mundo que atrapa y absorbe。 La épica que tiene la Primera Edad en todos y cada uno de sus cuentos e historias no tiene parangón。 La historia de Beren y Luthien es fundamental para comprender ese compendio de sucesos que se narran en El Silmarillion。 Aquí， al igual que en La Caída de Gondolin tenemos un análisis evolutivo de la historia de ambos personajes。 Una historia donde el a Tolkien nunca defrauda。 Cada vez que te adentras en uno de sus libros relacionados con la Tierra Media te metes en un mundo que atrapa y absorbe。 La épica que tiene la Primera Edad en todos y cada uno de sus cuentos e historias no tiene parangón。 La historia de Beren y Luthien es fundamental para comprender ese compendio de sucesos que se narran en El Silmarillion。 Aquí， al igual que en La Caída de Gondolin tenemos un análisis evolutivo de la historia de ambos personajes。 Una historia donde el amor está por encima de todas las cosas， y donde podemos reconocer fácilmente al propio autor en la figura de Beren， cuando partió a la guerra dejando a su amada。 También creo que esta historia es un gran ejemplo de feminismo heroico， pues Luthien no se limita a mirar， sino que es capaz de todo para salvar la vida de su amor。 Es la gran heroína de esta historia， y sin su magia el destino de la Tierra Media y de los silmarils habría sido muy diferente。En todo caso creo que este libro está un poco peor estructurado que La Caída de Gondolin， y a veces es un poco caótico ubicarse con los cambios narrativos de Tolkien si no has leído El Silmarillion。 No obstante sigo siendo fiel defensor de estos libros， que te aproximan de una forma más "mascadita" que en El Silmarillion algunos de los sucesos más importantes contados en ese libro。 Una vez más queda demostrado que Tolkien es el señor supremo de la fantasía épica， y nadie， por más que puedan intentarlo， logrará jamás crear un mundo tan rico， épico， heroico y bello como el de la Tierra Media。 。。。more
Peter Welch
，
Proving that you should read reviews before buying sometimes， unfortunately I found this somewhat disapointing。I was expecting a book which elaborated the tale of Beren and Luthien， in the same way that "The Children of Hurin" had extended that story also contained within "The Silmarillion"。 Instead you are presented with an original version of the story and then various additional texts from various manuscripts detailing the stories transformation。 I think this is one for hardcore Tolkien fans Proving that you should read reviews before buying sometimes， unfortunately I found this somewhat disapointing。I was expecting a book which elaborated the tale of Beren and Luthien， in the same way that "The Children of Hurin" had extended that story also contained within "The Silmarillion"。 Instead you are presented with an original version of the story and then various additional texts from various manuscripts detailing the stories transformation。 I think this is one for hardcore Tolkien fans only who already know the tale of Beren and Luthien from within "The Silmarillion"。 。。。more
Victoria Moschou
，
Lyrically beautiful， whimsical and epic， all at the same time， Beren and Luthien reminded me why J。 R。 R。 Tolkien remains until this very day the King of Epic Fantasy。I loved the descriptions， the elves lines and family trees， the different versions of the two lovers’ myth and how the entire story intertwined with what happened in The Silmarillion， The Hobbit and The Lord of The Rings。I highly recommend this book to every Epic Fantasy fan out there！You’ll find yourselves falling in love with poe Lyrically beautiful， whimsical and epic， all at the same time， Beren and Luthien reminded me why J。 R。 R。 Tolkien remains until this very day the King of Epic Fantasy。I loved the descriptions， the elves lines and family trees， the different versions of the two lovers’ myth and how the entire story intertwined with what happened in The Silmarillion， The Hobbit and The Lord of The Rings。I highly recommend this book to every Epic Fantasy fan out there！You’ll find yourselves falling in love with poetry; and it’ll be EPIC！ 。。。more
Becca
，
I don’t usually do well with stories written in verse but hot dog did Tolkien pack some fantastic and devastating lines in there Also -10/10 Tevildo， too much nightmare， good call scraping him for Sauron
Matthew John Andreoni
，
This version of the story reads mostly like a fairy tale， which I enjoyed a lot。 It’s my first taste of what Tolkien’s process was for revising his stories and the attitude he has towards his mythology and what would become the LOTR。 So dope， can’t wait for the other two great tales。
Terry Hayes
，
Been a while since I read this， but I was not a fan。 At least not as big a fan as I was of the first book dealing with the three main stories told in the Silmarillion， The Children of Hurin。 That book was essentially an expansion of the section of the Silmarillion with material added from Tolkien's notes and no "invention" as Christopher Tolkien put it。 This books really does not tell the tale in full anywhere。It has some information that it nice to know。 Like how the story developed from more o Been a while since I read this， but I was not a fan。 At least not as big a fan as I was of the first book dealing with the three main stories told in the Silmarillion， The Children of Hurin。 That book was essentially an expansion of the section of the Silmarillion with material added from Tolkien's notes and no "invention" as Christopher Tolkien put it。 This books really does not tell the tale in full anywhere。It has some information that it nice to know。 Like how the story developed from more of a fairy tale for children， with Beren being enslaved by a lord of cats and some other stuff， before it eventually evolved into more of a high myth。 But it never gives you any kind of coherent narrative。 Much closer to The Fall of Gondolin than Children of Hurin。 。。。more
Fabiola Castillo Autora
，
He sido megafan de Tolkien hace mas de 2 décadas y lo seguiré siendo。 Sin embargo， este libro me costó， a pesar de que ya había leído su contenido en Cuentos Perdidos y otros similares。 Es que a Cristopher le gustaba editar los libros de su padre en formato de ensayo， como un estudio fililogico， por así decirlo。 La estructura no es lineal ni narrativa， en estricto rigor。 Presenta diversas versiones de la historia， mostrando datos acerca de los cambios。 Así que es la misma trama en múltiples vers He sido megafan de Tolkien hace mas de 2 décadas y lo seguiré siendo。 Sin embargo， este libro me costó， a pesar de que ya había leído su contenido en Cuentos Perdidos y otros similares。 Es que a Cristopher le gustaba editar los libros de su padre en formato de ensayo， como un estudio fililogico， por así decirlo。 La estructura no es lineal ni narrativa， en estricto rigor。 Presenta diversas versiones de la historia， mostrando datos acerca de los cambios。 Así que es la misma trama en múltiples versiones。 Quiero enfatizar que la historia es maravillosa。 Para mí， la más personal que Tolkien escribió y una de las más antiguas。 Tenemos épica， romance， simbologia y espiritualidad。 Lo negativo es que no me gusta leer un cuento como si fuera un estudio antropológico。 Se interrumpe el ritmo de lectura。 La trama parte con un Beren elfo， no humano， en una historia que los elfos le cuentan a un hombre naufrago en su isla mágica。 Luego la historia evoluciona con Beren humano y adquiere más elementos que la enriquecen。 Lo mejor de Tolkien es como hila historias en una épica que trasciende tiempos y espacios。 Un Silmaril será parte de la historia de varios milenios， sin perder su valor simbólico。 Recomendado a verdaderos fan y lectores pacientes。 #jrrtolkien #berenyluthien 。。。more
Helena
，
herlighet， denne var tørr。
Reference
google book https://www.google.com/search?tbm=bks&q=Beren y Lúthien
hathitrust digital library https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/ls?q1=Beren y Lúthien&field1=ocr&a=srchls&ft=ft&lmt=ft
The British Library https://bll01.primo.exlibrisgroup.com/discovery/search?query=any,contains,Beren y Lúthien&tab=LibraryCatalog&search_scope=Not_BL_Suppress&vid=44BL_INST:BLL01&lang=en&offset=0