The Russian Understanding of War: Blurring the Lines between War and Peace

The Russian Understanding of War: Blurring the Lines between War and Peace

  • Downloads:2666
  • Type:Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
  • Create Date:2022-01-15 08:53:58
  • Update Date:2025-09-06
  • Status:finish
  • Author:Oscar Jonsson
  • ISBN:1626167346
  • Environment:PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle

Summary

This book analyzes the evolution of Russian military thought and how Russia's current thinking about war is reflected in recent crises。 While other books describe current Russian practice, Oscar Jonsson provides the long view to show how Russian military strategic thinking has developed from the Bolshevik Revolution to the present。 He closely examines Russian primary sources including security doctrines and the writings and statements of Russian military theorists and political elites。 What Jonsson reveals is that Russia's conception of the very nature of war is now changing, as Russian elites see information warfare and political subversion as the most important ways to conduct contemporary war。 Since information warfare and political subversion are below the traditional threshold of armed violence, this has blurred the boundaries between war and peace。 Jonsson also finds that Russian leaders have, particularly since 2011-12, considered themselves to be at war with the United States and its allies, albeit with non-violent means。 This book provides much needed context and analysis to be able to understand recent Russian interventions in Crimea and eastern Ukraine, how to deter Russia on the eastern borders of NATO, and how the West must also learn to avoid inadvertent escalation。

Download

Reviews

Jeff

Very informative and a compelling argument。 The only problem is that the author seems to take public statements made by Russian leaders at face value。 This is problematic, at least for understanding how Russian decision makers view war and conflict, because they’re chronic liars。

Alex Courtney

This is not a book for the casual reader but I would call it an indespensible book for anyone interested in national security studies。 The author builds a strong case for his views on the evolution of Russian security thought by quoting from major thinkers in their own words。 Like any good theory, it explains observable phenomena in the world with such accuracy that at the end this reader's response is "Oh, it was there the whole time。" This is not a book for the casual reader but I would call it an indespensible book for anyone interested in national security studies。 The author builds a strong case for his views on the evolution of Russian security thought by quoting from major thinkers in their own words。 Like any good theory, it explains observable phenomena in the world with such accuracy that at the end this reader's response is "Oh, it was there the whole time。" 。。。more

Peter G

Highlights Russian doctrinal understanding of manipulation and wraponizatiin of information in conjunction with armed conflict or war

Marshall

Excellent overview of Russia’s evolution of the concept of war from Soviet times to the present。

Allie

The best book I’ve read on how Russia sees the future of warfare - 100% in the information space, which is seen (in their eyes) as just effective as kinetic action。

Alice

I learned a new way to think about the actions of the Russian government from this well-researched book。

Scott Martin

(Audiobook) Normally, a book about military doctrine can serve as a great substitute for a sleep aid, or primarily serves as a resource to find the obligatory dead-guy quotes someone needs for an academic presentation。 However, this work manages to offer insight into Russian military doctrine and their philosophy of warfare, and while it is a theory, it is one that seems to be borne out in the actions of the Russian leaders especially in the past few years。 According to the research of Jonsson, (Audiobook) Normally, a book about military doctrine can serve as a great substitute for a sleep aid, or primarily serves as a resource to find the obligatory dead-guy quotes someone needs for an academic presentation。 However, this work manages to offer insight into Russian military doctrine and their philosophy of warfare, and while it is a theory, it is one that seems to be borne out in the actions of the Russian leaders especially in the past few years。 According to the research of Jonsson, Russian's view of war dates back to the writings and analysis of Lenin, noting the political aspect of war, almost matching Clausewitz's maxim about war being the continuation of policy by other means。 However, Lenin amplified the political struggle/nature of war, especially how it fit in the class/economic struggle。 Other Soviet/Russian theorists offered their contributions。 A key theme that eventually emerged out of those writings and the present day is that Russia does not view war as simply armed engagement。 The contests in the information realm, cyber and propaganda are as much a weapon for Russia as their subs and nuclear triad。 The idea of subversion and using information/disinformation to weaken an adversary from within is a recent act of the Russian military but not a recent theory。 Officers on the Tzarist (White) side of the Russian Civil War offered their insights that influenced Reds and Russians decades after the fact。 For Russia, they feel that they are in a state of political conflict/war with the US and the West, and while they are necessarily shooting weapons, they are using political and informational means to attack their adversaries to advance their aims and defend against perceived threats。 Theories are always open to intrepretation and challenge, and this work is no exception。 It seems to discount older aspects of Russian history and thought that have significant influence on the present day, but what analysis and insight Lacey provides is based on good information and logic。 It is a good starting point for analysis of the Russian problem set。 The reader is solid, especially with something as dry as doctrine。 Worth it for a Russian scholar or one who wants some insight into Russian political/military aims。 。。。more