Bitter Reckoning: Israel Tries Holocaust Survivors as Nazi Collaborators

Bitter Reckoning: Israel Tries Holocaust Survivors as Nazi Collaborators

  • Downloads:6400
  • Type:Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
  • Create Date:2021-09-14 09:55:51
  • Update Date:2025-09-07
  • Status:finish
  • Author:Dan Porat
  • ISBN:0674988140
  • Environment:PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle

Summary

Beginning in 1950, the state of Israel prosecuted and jailed dozens of Holocaust survivors who had served as camp kapos or ghetto police under the Nazis。 At last comes the first full account of the kapo trials, based on records newly declassified after forty years。



In December 1945, a Polish-born commuter on a Tel Aviv bus recognized a fellow rider as the former head of a town council the Nazis had established to manage the Jews。 When he denounced the man as a collaborator, the rider leapt off the bus, pursued by passengers intent on beating him to death。 Five years later, to address ongoing tensions within Holocaust survivor communities, the State of Israel instituted the criminal prosecution of Jews who had served as ghetto administrators or kapos in concentration camps。

Dan Porat brings to light more than three dozen little-known trials, held over the following two decades, of survivors charged with Nazi collaboration。 Scouring police investigation files and trial records, he found accounts of Jewish policemen and camp functionaries who harassed, beat, robbed, and even murdered their brethren。 But as the trials exposed the tragic experiences of the kapos, over time the courts and the public shifted from seeing them as evil collaborators to victims themselves, and the fervor to prosecute them abated。

Porat shows how these trials changed Israel's understanding of the Holocaust and explores how the suppression of the trial records--long classified by the state--affected history and memory。 Sensitive to the devastating options confronting those who chose to collaborate, yet rigorous in its analysis, Bitter Reckoning invites us to rethink our ideas of complicity and justice and to consider what it means to be a victim in extraordinary circumstances。

Download

Reviews

Relstuart

One of the fascinating ideas from the Bitter Reckoning book was the growing acceptance over time of the idea in Jewish society that they couldn't judge a collaborator who worked with the Nazis to abuse and kill other Jews。 This isn't talking about people who merely looked the other way while others suffered。 But people who actively participated in rounding up other Jews to send to concentration camps or served as overseers in the concentration camps。 In the social media age where we casually con One of the fascinating ideas from the Bitter Reckoning book was the growing acceptance over time of the idea in Jewish society that they couldn't judge a collaborator who worked with the Nazis to abuse and kill other Jews。 This isn't talking about people who merely looked the other way while others suffered。 But people who actively participated in rounding up other Jews to send to concentration camps or served as overseers in the concentration camps。 In the social media age where we casually condemn/damn people on a regular basis, this idea, which became a powerful force leading light or no sentences for some collaborators, felt foreign。 It's hard to imagine the horror felt by some of the people in this book having lived through the Holocaust, moved from Europe to Israel to start a new safe society, looking up one day going about your business and seeing someone who helped kill your family in a concentration camp casually going about ordinary life。 This sort of event happened to people and is why the trials recounted in this book happened。 。。。more

Karen Levi

I read this book on recommendation from a professor who leads annual trips to the concentration camps in Poland。 I participated in such a trip this past December。 An excellent book, though some passages were dry for me。 I am not a legal scholar。 During the post war period in the new country of Israel, Holocaust survivors were zealous to convict the Jewish police, community leaders, and concentration camp Kapos。 Often street fights broke out when citizens sighted these so-called collaborators。 Pa I read this book on recommendation from a professor who leads annual trips to the concentration camps in Poland。 I participated in such a trip this past December。 An excellent book, though some passages were dry for me。 I am not a legal scholar。 During the post war period in the new country of Israel, Holocaust survivors were zealous to convict the Jewish police, community leaders, and concentration camp Kapos。 Often street fights broke out when citizens sighted these so-called collaborators。 Partly to prevent uncontrollable violence, the courts began to prosecute these unfortunate individuals。 After the Eichmann trial in 1961, it became evident that Jewish people who may have willingly or unwillingly aided the Nazis could not be considered the same as actual Nazis。 As time went on into the 1970’s, the Israelis recognized that these people were victims of horrendous circumstances and probably acted with self preservation and interest in mind。rather than evil intentions。The author begins and concludes the book with the thoughts of Primo Levi。 Mr。 Levi was an Italian Holocaust survivor who contended that the majority of victims of the Shoah were neither inherently good or bad but existed in a “gray zone”。 Most of us would be in the gray zone。 We do not know how we would act starved, beaten, humiliated, frightened, lost, bewildered, and shocked by witnessing and experiencing man’s capacity for evil on a daily basis。 It is Primo Levi’s philosophy that reconciles the question of the guilt or innocence of Jewish community leaders and Kapos for Dan Pirates, the author。 。。。more