The Peoples of Middle-earth

The Peoples of Middle-earth

  • Downloads:3866
  • Type:Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
  • Create Date:2021-07-26 09:54:33
  • Update Date:2025-09-06
  • Status:finish
  • Author:J.R.R. Tolkien
  • ISBN:0261103482
  • Environment:PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle

Summary

When J。R。R。 Tolkien laid aside The Silmarillion in 1937 the extension of the originall 'mythology' into later Ages of the world had scarcely begun。 It was in the Appendices to The Lord of the Rings that there emerged a comprehensive historical structure and chronology of the Second and Third Ages, embracing all the diverse strands that came together in the War of the Ring。 The difficulty that he found in providing these Appendices, leading to the delay in the publication of The Return of the King, is well known, but in The Peoples of Middle-earth Christopher Tolkien shows that early forms of these works already existed years before, in essays and records differing greatly from the published forms。 He traces the evolution of the Calendars, the Hobbit genealogies, the Westron language or Common Speach (from which many words and names are recorded that were afterwards lost), and the chronological structure of the later Ages。

Other writings by J。R。R。 Tolkien are included in this final volume of The History of MIddle-earth, chiefly deriving from his last years, when new insights and new constructions still freely arose as he pondered the history that he had created。 This book concludes with two soon-abandoned stories, both unique in the setting of time and place: The New Shadow in Gondor of the Fourth Age, and the tale of Tal-elmar, in which the coming of the dreaded Númenórean ships is seen through the eyes of men of Middle-earth in the Dark Years。

Download

Reviews

Carlos Bennett

Uno de mis favoritos de la serie。 Probablemente porque complementa los Apéndices (que son uno de mis textos favoritos), y porque tiene los únicos textos de la cuarta edad, posteriores al Señor de los Anillos。 De verdad una joya。Reflexión general sobre los 12 volúmenes de "La historia de la Tierra Media"。 Mucho se ha dicho de que gran parte del valor de El Señor de Anillos está en la sensación que Tolkien crea de que hay algo más grande detrás: una mitología。 Se mencionan a la pasada personajes, Uno de mis favoritos de la serie。 Probablemente porque complementa los Apéndices (que son uno de mis textos favoritos), y porque tiene los únicos textos de la cuarta edad, posteriores al Señor de los Anillos。 De verdad una joya。Reflexión general sobre los 12 volúmenes de "La historia de la Tierra Media"。 Mucho se ha dicho de que gran parte del valor de El Señor de Anillos está en la sensación que Tolkien crea de que hay algo más grande detrás: una mitología。 Se mencionan a la pasada personajes, historias, canciones que aluden a algo más grande, algo que está bosquejado en el Silmarillion。 Pero pese a que Tolkien es uno de los más grandes influenciadores en la historia, esto en realidad no logra funcionar de la misma manera en nadie más。 Si se mencionan nombres o historias antiguas a la pasada, que no están desarrolladas en ninguna parte y que no están incluidas en el arco mayor, la mitología se siente pobre, antojadiza, puesta ahí para espesar un poco un mundo que en verdad es liviano。 Si la historia-marco por el contrario se cuenta en un libro con todo detalle (como lo que hizo GRR Martin con Fire and Blood, o las precuelas de DUNE, etc)。。。 pues deja de ser mitología。 Pasa a ser más historia。 En Tolkien, uno sabe que hay un mundo pensado tanto al detalle como también en sus grandes arcos, pero además es un mundo que no está totalmente definido: esta descrito en cientos de manuscritos, algunos que se contradicen, con nombres que cambian, sutiles diferencias en la historia, detalles anotados a pie de página。。。 es un verdadero mito, al que solo se puede acceder por los trabajos de arqueología que hizo Christopher Tolkien。 Esto puede ser un poco extra-literario (o meta-literario), pero es parte de las circunstancias irrepetibles que convierten al mundo de Tolkien en lo que es。 Es magia。 。。。more

Melissa

I’m not going to lie, I struggled with the beginning of this one, the language and family tree developments have never been my favorites, or the calendars and dating discrepancies, BUT by the second half of Part I, when more stories started mingling in with that info then it really picked up for me。 So if you are also lagging with this one, it does pick up! And with this one, I can officially say I have finished all of The Histories Of Middle Earth! Whew!

Stephen Poltz

This is the final book in the History of Middle Earth (HoME) series。 It was also one of the more interesting。 It covers the appendices from The Lord of the Rings, etymological and phonological changes to names throughout the legendarium, contemplation of logical problems with names and people, and lastly includes two unfinished stories。 I have to admit, the language section was a bit of a slog, giving the development of names and the two elvish language (Quenya and Sindar) versions of the names。 This is the final book in the History of Middle Earth (HoME) series。 It was also one of the more interesting。 It covers the appendices from The Lord of the Rings, etymological and phonological changes to names throughout the legendarium, contemplation of logical problems with names and people, and lastly includes two unfinished stories。 I have to admit, the language section was a bit of a slog, giving the development of names and the two elvish language (Quenya and Sindar) versions of the names。 One might argue that most of the HoME series dealt in the development of names, which wouldn’t be a lie, as Tolkien continually changed names and dates as his legendarium developed from 1917 until his death in 1973。 But the rest was more interesting than usual。 Come visit my blog for the full review…https://itstartedwiththehugos。blogspo。。。 。。。more

Michael Joosten

The Peoples of Middle-earth was the first volume of the HoME I bought with my own money--indeed, the first Tolkien book I bought with my own money, having previously subsisted off the books my Dad owned or what the local library offered。 Of the HoME volumes I had not yet encountered, it was the most interesting--at least in its final pages, where it was like an addendum to Unfinished Tales, which might just be the best posthumous book by Tolkien (depends on my mood, but it'd be a real difficult The Peoples of Middle-earth was the first volume of the HoME I bought with my own money--indeed, the first Tolkien book I bought with my own money, having previously subsisted off the books my Dad owned or what the local library offered。 Of the HoME volumes I had not yet encountered, it was the most interesting--at least in its final pages, where it was like an addendum to Unfinished Tales, which might just be the best posthumous book by Tolkien (depends on my mood, but it'd be a real difficult choice deciding if it was that or the 77 Silm going to a desert island "if I could only take one")。In event, the third or so of the book that follows the history of the Appendices doesn't disappoint, and the History of the Appendices, which sounds like something only a Tolkien fan who drinks ALL the Kool-Aid would love, is something this Tolkien fan-who-does-indeed-drink-all-the-Kool-Aid does, indeed, love。This volume is arguably the first, and only, one of the HoME to add things about the Third Age that can be taken as canon--things cut from the Appendices: the Boffin and Bolger genealogies, more "true Westron" names, the genealogy of the House of Dol Amroth。 The essays, "Of Dwarves and Men" and "The Shibboleth of Fëanor" are, despite their incomplete states, too good to have been left out of Unfinished Tales, and "The New Shadow" and "Tal-Elmar" would be worth the price of admission alone。There is a potential for great sadness reaching the end of The Peoples of Middle-earth, for though the proverbial wastebasket is not quite emptied when you get there, this is the last of the major bits of new material on Middle-earth (SPOILER: I am REALLY excited to see what's in "The Nature of Middle-earth")。 It doesn't just wrap up the project started in 1982, but the project started in 1977: The Silmarillion was the true "first volume" of the HoME, the sine qua non of the series。 After Tal-Elmar's shores, Christopher Tolkien brings no more new Middle-earth to us: there are some repackagings and some non-Middle-earthen pieces, but the works of Arda, the works generated and inhabited by "Elvish and Gnomish" are here wrapped up。But--and maybe this is how conditioned I am by Tolkien, that I think this way--this doesn't feel like a heartbreak to me。 Instead, there is a dwindling, a fading, and it seems fitting to me that the last "new Middle-earth" I had is a tale in which the Eldar are only a rumour and in which the fictional languages are not Quenya or Sindarin or Adûnaic but some unlovely names belonging to a forgotten tribe of the Dark Years。 It is fitting, after twelve volumes, that it doesn't end in narrative, but in a narrative that dwindles to speculation and outline, and that it is endcapped finally by Christopher Tolkien's numbered footnotes。 。。。more

Book-girl

I've been putting off writing reviews for the 12 history of middle earth parts。But now that I reached the end I can't muster upp any energy。 So this will be a short little review for all the books。 I love LOTR and felt it was a must to read these。 I probably shouldn't have, especially since I don't really enjoy reading books like this。 But since I read children of hurin and ended up loving it, I decided to confront this huge mass of history。Well it wasn't horrific, I think。 To be honest I felt l I've been putting off writing reviews for the 12 history of middle earth parts。But now that I reached the end I can't muster upp any energy。 So this will be a short little review for all the books。 I love LOTR and felt it was a must to read these。 I probably shouldn't have, especially since I don't really enjoy reading books like this。 But since I read children of hurin and ended up loving it, I decided to confront this huge mass of history。Well it wasn't horrific, I think。 To be honest I felt like read everything ten times and alot my eyes just gazed right by。There were some interesting tidbids and fun stuff in here。 So wouldn't say a complete waste of time。 But overall lesson learned, just beacause I love this incredible world doesn't necesserialy mean I would love reading about it like this。 I sorta feel like I dont have the strenght to read anything more of Tolkiens creations for atleast a long while。 。。。more

di9girl

An excellent end to an excellent series! If you come to love Tolkien and Middle-earth then this series of books is a must for your collection!

Thijs

The last part, and one of the best ones in the series!It has a lot of new material, such as the infamous 'New Shadow'。 Which though it reads very well, and would have made an amazing book, I am still glad it was not finished, for it would not have felt Lord of the Rings enough。 The mythical has disappeared。 This part is especially rich in the history on the Second Era。 And since we see least of those, I was very excited about these! Also the parts about the Dwarves, though they offer less insigh The last part, and one of the best ones in the series!It has a lot of new material, such as the infamous 'New Shadow'。 Which though it reads very well, and would have made an amazing book, I am still glad it was not finished, for it would not have felt Lord of the Rings enough。 The mythical has disappeared。 This part is especially rich in the history on the Second Era。 And since we see least of those, I was very excited about these! Also the parts about the Dwarves, though they offer less insight then I'd hoped, they still offered a deeper view of this always enigmatic race。Indeed, Tal-elmar was a very good finisher。 Very different from the rest of Tolkien's works in tone, though familiar。 Had I been able to give my life so he could have finished even twice the number of tales he did in his lifetime, I would have。 。。。more

Michael Pryor

Unparalleled, unmistakable, unsurpassed。

Warren Dunn

After reading this, I have finally decided that I am not even remotely interested in linguistics or phonology。 I have also concluded that I do certainly enjoy the history of Arnor and Gondor, in a completely different way from the Lord of the Rings。 But to the point that I was dismissing the hobbit sections in favour of the Numenorean sections。http://ossuslibrary。tripod。com/Bk_Fan。。。 After reading this, I have finally decided that I am not even remotely interested in linguistics or phonology。 I have also concluded that I do certainly enjoy the history of Arnor and Gondor, in a completely different way from the Lord of the Rings。 But to the point that I was dismissing the hobbit sections in favour of the Numenorean sections。http://ossuslibrary。tripod。com/Bk_Fan。。。 。。。more

Mitch Milam

If any fantasy author claims to have created a better world than Tolkien, just slam all 12 copies of HoME down on the table and tell them to take a damn seat。

Max

I loved this final installment of the History of Middle Earth series。 This part mainly focuses on the appendices of the Lord of the Rings, so many of the favourite characters are in this volume。 There was some problem with finishing the appendices in time when the Return of the King was published and when you read this book, it's apparent why。 They're so detailed and there is a lot of it。Great book, one of the better ones of the series。 As always, only for hardcore Tolkien fanatics, it might be I loved this final installment of the History of Middle Earth series。 This part mainly focuses on the appendices of the Lord of the Rings, so many of the favourite characters are in this volume。 There was some problem with finishing the appendices in time when the Return of the King was published and when you read this book, it's apparent why。 They're so detailed and there is a lot of it。Great book, one of the better ones of the series。 As always, only for hardcore Tolkien fanatics, it might be a bit boring for the casual reader。 。。。more

♣Edso ♣Y♣

The climax is hands downs amaizing。

Ryan Creech

how tf do you read this

Mary Catelli

This is more about the writing of The Lord of the Rings -- to be more precise, of its Appendices。 It fares wide and far over the whole of Middle-Earth。 From scraps about making Celerimbor a descendant of Feanor, which made it necessary to work out which of his sons married, to Tolkien working out the "original" hobbit names that were "translated" to the forms in LOTR, down to the solemn observation that "Lobelia" is merely his best guess as to the flower she was named after。 Ideas he played with This is more about the writing of The Lord of the Rings -- to be more precise, of its Appendices。 It fares wide and far over the whole of Middle-Earth。 From scraps about making Celerimbor a descendant of Feanor, which made it necessary to work out which of his sons married, to Tolkien working out the "original" hobbit names that were "translated" to the forms in LOTR, down to the solemn observation that "Lobelia" is merely his best guess as to the flower she was named after。 Ideas he played with, such as the question of whether Tar-Miriel was unwilling to marry Ar-Pharazon, and the story where one of Feanor's twin sons died at the Burning of the Ships。 。。。more

PottWab Regional Library

SM

Jeremy

This final volume of the mammoth History of Middle Earth has a romantic appeal, since it contains within it the very last writings by Tolkien, aged 80-1, about his beloved creation。 These last writings are the highlight of this book, particularly the passages on Dwarves and Men, and the Shibboleth of Feanor。 The book closes with two attempts at new stories of Middle Earth by Tolkien, unfinished at very early stages。 They are of interest, I believe, mostly as inspirations to other writers。 But wo This final volume of the mammoth History of Middle Earth has a romantic appeal, since it contains within it the very last writings by Tolkien, aged 80-1, about his beloved creation。 These last writings are the highlight of this book, particularly the passages on Dwarves and Men, and the Shibboleth of Feanor。 The book closes with two attempts at new stories of Middle Earth by Tolkien, unfinished at very early stages。 They are of interest, I believe, mostly as inspirations to other writers。 But worth reading for any lover of Tolkien。 。。。more

Eleanor

This was such a lovely and interesting read! I haven't read any Tolkien books in quite a while, so it was wonderful to return to my all-time favorite fantasy universe - and the one that holds the dearest place in my heart。 The variety of material kept me from getting bored by any one topic, and many of the angles and subjects explored were very fascinating。 The Shibboleth of Fëanor and Of Dwarves and Men were two of my favorite parts。 I'd definitely recommend this to anyone with an interest in t This was such a lovely and interesting read! I haven't read any Tolkien books in quite a while, so it was wonderful to return to my all-time favorite fantasy universe - and the one that holds the dearest place in my heart。 The variety of material kept me from getting bored by any one topic, and many of the angles and subjects explored were very fascinating。 The Shibboleth of Fëanor and Of Dwarves and Men were two of my favorite parts。 I'd definitely recommend this to anyone with an interest in the history of the Lord of the Rings, a look inside the mind of an author when developing mythology, or the languages (particularly Elvish, although much is also spoken of Westron, Khuzdul, and an ancient Hobbit tongue) of Middle-earth。 。。。more

Ahmad Sharabiani

The Peoples of Middle-earth (The History of Middle-Earth #12), J。R。R。 Tolkien, Christopher Tolkien (Editor)The Peoples of Middle-earth (1996) is the 12th and final volume of The History of Middle-earth, edited by Christopher Tolkien from the unpublished manuscripts of his father J。 R。 R。 Tolkien。 Some characters (including Anairë, the wife of Fingolfin) only appear here, as do a few other works that did not fit anywhere else。 تاریخ نخستین خوانش: روز هجدهم ماه ژوئن سال 2011 میلادیعنوان: مردمان سر The Peoples of Middle-earth (The History of Middle-Earth #12), J。R。R。 Tolkien, Christopher Tolkien (Editor)The Peoples of Middle-earth (1996) is the 12th and final volume of The History of Middle-earth, edited by Christopher Tolkien from the unpublished manuscripts of his father J。 R。 R。 Tolkien。 Some characters (including Anairë, the wife of Fingolfin) only appear here, as do a few other works that did not fit anywhere else。 تاریخ نخستین خوانش: روز هجدهم ماه ژوئن سال 2011 میلادیعنوان: مردمان سرزمین میانه: کتاب دوازدهم از تاریخ سرزمین میانه؛ نویسنده: جان روئل رونالد تالکین؛ ویراستار کریستوفر تالکین؛ موضوع: داستانهای نویسندگان انگلیسی - سده 20ممردمان سرزمین میانه: «کریستوفر تالکین» در صفحات آغازین هر یک از مجلدهای مجموعه تاریخ «سرزمین میانه» متناسب با محوریت کتاب نوشته ای مختصر با الفبای تنگوار به ثبت رسانده است؛ در ابتدای دوازدهمین و آخرین جلد این مجموعه، این را میخوانیم: «این آخرین مجلد از کار کریستوفر تالکین است که طی آن بخش عظیمی از تمام آنچه را که پدرش جان رونالد روئل تالکین پیرامون سرزمین میانه و والینور یادداشت کرده است را گرد هم آورده است؛ در این کتاب تدوین و تشکیل تاریحچه بخش شمال غربی سرزمین میانه پس از جنگ بزرگ و سقوط مورگوت در دوران های بعدی به ثبت رسیده است。»؛این مجلد که با نام «مردمان سرزمین میانه» در ماه سپتامبر سال 1996میلادی در انگلستان، و در ماه دسامبر همانسال در آمریکا به چاپ رسید، بخش اعظم آن حاوی اولین ویرایشهای ضمایم و مقدمه های داستان های تالکین است؛ نظیر: ضمیمه آکالابت در سیلماریلیون، ضمایم زبان شناسی، شجره نامه ها و ضمیمه الف ارباب حلقه ها。؛ همچنین در این کتاب آخرین یادداشت های جی。آر。آر تالکین از تکامل زبان کوئنیا و مقالاتی همچون «حدیث دورفها و انسانها» و «مشکلات روس» که به بیان نقش گرامری پسوند «روس» در اسامی چون «الروس» و «مایدروس» آمده است میپردازد؛ در این کتاب همچنین درباره «ایستاری» و «گلورفیندل گوندولینی» و «گلورفیندل ریوندلی» بحث شده است؛ و سرانجام دو داستان ناتمام و در واقع آخرین داستان های «تالکین» از «سرزمین میانه» که بسیار ناتمام باقی ماندند، در آخرین بخشِ آخرین جلد مجموعه ی «تاریخ سرزمین میانه» به چاپ رسیده که عبارتست از داستان «تار-المار» و داستان «سایه جدید» که داستانی در دوران چهارم «سرزمین میانه» و هنگام فرمانروایی «الداریون» فرزند «آراگورن» و «آرون» بوده، که تنها اشارات بسیار کوچکی از آن موجود استتاریخ بهنگام رسانی 04/06/1399هجری خورشیدی؛ ا。 شربیانی 。。。more

Andre

For the series as a whole。 This is a lot of information, presented in a very academic fashion that brings a greater understanding of the writing process and logic behind the LOTR world。 Overall my appreciation for the work done by Christopher Tolkien has increased and my love of the world of LOTR has decreased。 Apart from a few elements, I did not discover anything that excited me and saw limits to the logic and breadth of the world that I had not seen before。 Thus it was an enlightening read in For the series as a whole。 This is a lot of information, presented in a very academic fashion that brings a greater understanding of the writing process and logic behind the LOTR world。 Overall my appreciation for the work done by Christopher Tolkien has increased and my love of the world of LOTR has decreased。 Apart from a few elements, I did not discover anything that excited me and saw limits to the logic and breadth of the world that I had not seen before。 Thus it was an enlightening read in regards to the writing process and the limits of the world but it did not make it love it more。 As mentioned for every other book in the series : for hard-core fans only。 。。。more

Dan

a couple good bits only, like what happened with Aragorn and Arwen。 Also, the origins of Saruman, Gandalf and the other 3 wizards。

Rossrn Nunamaker

Volume 12 of 12 in the History of Middle Earth, The Peoples of Middle-Earth, compiled by Christopher Tolkien, is in many ways my favorite of the ones I've read (I've read the first two volumes and last six)。This volume primarily covers the Prologue and Appendices of LOTR, but it sneaks in a few selections touched upon in Unfinished Tales and provides to two gems in the final section "The New Shadow" and "Tal-Elmar"。The New Shadow, published for the first time in this volume, is the start to a se Volume 12 of 12 in the History of Middle Earth, The Peoples of Middle-Earth, compiled by Christopher Tolkien, is in many ways my favorite of the ones I've read (I've read the first two volumes and last six)。This volume primarily covers the Prologue and Appendices of LOTR, but it sneaks in a few selections touched upon in Unfinished Tales and provides to two gems in the final section "The New Shadow" and "Tal-Elmar"。The New Shadow, published for the first time in this volume, is the start to a sequel of LOTR。 Admittedly, it doesn't go far enough to guess or speculate where JRR was going with this and the notes mention that he wasn't fond of the idea in the first place, but it remains intriguing as to what happened in the 4th Age and here we get a glimpse of what might have happened。Tal-Elmar is intriguing because it is told from the perspective of the "Wild Men" about the Numenoreans。 The change of perspective was wonderful and I wish there had been more of it to read。The first part of the volume is also the longest and covers the prologue and appendices, what I liked about this was the background provided。For fans of Tolkien, this is a great read and well worth the effort to read。 。。。more

Ashwise

Another indepth look of the appendices, including culture and an abandoned sequel。 Totally worth the read if you love Tolkein!

Zachames

With every new Tolkien volume I read, it becomes more and more apparent that he was not simply a fantasy author but one of those rare artists whose art seems to have a soul all its own。

Neil R。 Coulter

And here we are: the final volume of the History of Middle-Earth。 For this last entry, Christopher Tolkien goes back to the Lord of the Rings, showing his father's development of what became the Appendices。 I remember after finishing the four volumes of the History of the Lord of the Rings (volumes 6-9 of the History of Middle-Earth) feeling that it didn't seem quite finished。 The History of the Lord of the Rings felt weighted heavily to the side of Tolkien's beginning of the story, with a rushe And here we are: the final volume of the History of Middle-Earth。 For this last entry, Christopher Tolkien goes back to the Lord of the Rings, showing his father's development of what became the Appendices。 I remember after finishing the four volumes of the History of the Lord of the Rings (volumes 6-9 of the History of Middle-Earth) feeling that it didn't seem quite finished。 The History of the Lord of the Rings felt weighted heavily to the side of Tolkien's beginning of the story, with a rushed, incomplete account of the finishing。 So I was happy to go back, in Volume 12, to the finishing touches of the Lord of the Rings。 Also, it happens that there are a lot of fascinating details in the writing and revising of the Appendices (though others in my family did not always share my excitement about the ways that Tolkien translated Hobbit names into the published form)。 The middle of the book, with a long section on phonological changes in Quenya and Sindarin, was a bit of a slog for me。 Interesting as a reference for Tolkien's linguistic creation, but not as engrossing (for me at this time, at least) for simply reading start to finish。 I'd hoped that the end of the book would include some kind of reflections from Christopher, looking back over his own journey through the decades he's worked on his father's unpublished material。 I would've enjoyed even a brief Afterword, something of a "Here's what it feels like to be at the end of this project。" But no, there's nothing like that; the book just ends。 In some ways Christopher has shown himself to be rather unsentimental (though one might suggest that the entire History project is thoroughly sentimental)。 But the last section of the book brings me back to what attracted me to Middle-Earth to begin with: not phonology, geography, or calendars, but story。 My interest in digging deeper into Tolkien's creative process got me through many pages of detail about minute changes to maps, the logic behind linguistic choices, changes in the numbers of days in each month for different peoples of Middle-Earth, and so forth。 But I first loved Middle-Earth because of the stories。 And so I think it's beautiful that the History series concludes with two unfinished stories--one from after the death of Aragorn, and one from earlier, when the Numenoreans were landing on the western shores of Middle-Earth。 I liked seeing that even at the end of his life, Tolkien himself was pushing out the borders of the storytelling, finding new places to learn about and new narrative perspectives on the history of his subcreation。 This has been a wonderful journey through the development of Middle-Earth。 Parts of the books I'll go back to occasionally, and I do think I will someday read through the entire series again。 。。。more

Tommy Grooms

Much of the final volume of the History of Middle-earth series shows Tolkien at his niggling zenith, as he works out timelines and linguistic history in an attempt to make his work a cohesive whole。 Most of the history consists of minor developments that aren't inherently interesting (other than showing the kind of strain he was under in finalizing the appendices of The Lord of the Rings), but his linguistic work in this volume demonstrates better than any other how much Tolkien's philology drov Much of the final volume of the History of Middle-earth series shows Tolkien at his niggling zenith, as he works out timelines and linguistic history in an attempt to make his work a cohesive whole。 Most of the history consists of minor developments that aren't inherently interesting (other than showing the kind of strain he was under in finalizing the appendices of The Lord of the Rings), but his linguistic work in this volume demonstrates better than any other how much Tolkien's philology drove his storytelling。 His final writings include an abortive sequel showing the rise of a new orkish cult and a tale showing the arrival of the Numenorians from the eyes of the men of Middle-earth: both woefully short。 It's bittersweet to finish the last of Tolkien's Middle-earth material on Tolkien Reading Day, and I can only express awe at the size and scope of his legendarium。 。。。more

Breana Melvin

A good amount of new information in this one。 So weird to finally be done with all 12 of these。

Christa

This is mainly a much expanded and annotated volume comprised of the appendices to "Lord of the Rings。" For the hardcore Tolkien fan, the additional information added to the story will be appreciated。 The notes by Christopher Tolkien add some additional information, but often serve to inform the avid Tolkienite about the development of the unpinning myths that surround the core story of "The Lord of the Rings。" Some of the notes recount revisions, bridge gaps in the available information, or try This is mainly a much expanded and annotated volume comprised of the appendices to "Lord of the Rings。" For the hardcore Tolkien fan, the additional information added to the story will be appreciated。 The notes by Christopher Tolkien add some additional information, but often serve to inform the avid Tolkienite about the development of the unpinning myths that surround the core story of "The Lord of the Rings。" Some of the notes recount revisions, bridge gaps in the available information, or try to reconcile different accounts。Much of the information found here can also be found in more concise, polished form in books like "The Silmarillion," but the appendices, in general, serve as a good summary of those stories for someone who isn't interested enough to read "The Silmarillion。" That same person, though, would find this book to be over the top, I'm sure。I use this book as more of a reference book, looking up questionable points and looking for explanations as needed。 Right now, I only own this volume, covering only the appendices of the series。 。。。more

Sara

I say I read this, but have really used it as a reference book rather than tackling it as a book to sit down and read。 It is a collection of the manuscripts and notes on the Prologue and the Appendices to the Lord of the Rings, and some sections of the published Silmarillion (Akallabeth)complied and annotated by Christopher Tolkien。 Other tidbits include the Shibboleth of Feanor, primarily about Elvish languages, Last Writings late in Tolkien's life on Glorfindel, Cirdan, and the Five Wizards。Th I say I read this, but have really used it as a reference book rather than tackling it as a book to sit down and read。 It is a collection of the manuscripts and notes on the Prologue and the Appendices to the Lord of the Rings, and some sections of the published Silmarillion (Akallabeth)complied and annotated by Christopher Tolkien。 Other tidbits include the Shibboleth of Feanor, primarily about Elvish languages, Last Writings late in Tolkien's life on Glorfindel, Cirdan, and the Five Wizards。This final, 12th volume of the History of Middle-earth contains two further unfinished tales - one started in the Fourth Age of Middle Earth and another in the Second Age。 I am saving reading these until I have read everything else Tolkien published。 。。。more