The People's Hospital: Hope and Peril in American Medicine
- Downloads：8264
- Type：Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
- Create Date：2023-03-16 17:21:26
- Update Date：2025-09-06
- Status：finish
- Author：Ricardo Nuila
- ISBN：1501198041
- Environment：PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle
- Download
Summary
Where does one go without health insurance， when turned away by hospitals， clinics， and doctors？ In The People’s Hospital ， physician Ricardo Nuila’s stunning debut， we follow the lives of five uninsured Houstonians as their struggle for survival leads them to a hospital where insurance comes second to genuine care。
First， we meet Stephen， the restaurant franchise manager who signed up for his company’s lowest priced plan， only to find himself facing insurmountable costs after a cancer diagnosis。 Then Christian—a young college student and retail worker who can’t seem to get an accurate diagnosis， let alone treatment， for his debilitating knee pain。 Geronimo， thirty-six years old， has liver failure， but his meager disability check disqualifies him for Medicaid—and puts a life-saving transplant just out of reach。 Roxana， who’s lived in the community without a visa for more than two decades， suffers from complications related to her cancer treatment。 And finally， there’s Ebonie， a young mother whose high-risk pregnancy endangers her life。 Whether due to immigration status， income， or the vagaries of state Medicaid law， all five are denied access to care。 For all five， this exclusion could prove life-threatening。
Each patient eventually lands at Ben Taub， the county hospital where Dr。 Nuila has worked for over a decade。 Nuila delves with empathy into the experiences of his patients， braiding their dramas into a singular narrative that contradicts the established idea that the only way to receive good healthcare is with good insurance。 As readers follow the movingly rendered twists and turns in each patient’s story， it’s impossible to deny that our system is broken—and that Ben Taub’s innovative model， which emphasizes people over payments， could help light the path forward。
First， we meet Stephen， the restaurant franchise manager who signed up for his company’s lowest priced plan， only to find himself facing insurmountable costs after a cancer diagnosis。 Then Christian—a young college student and retail worker who can’t seem to get an accurate diagnosis， let alone treatment， for his debilitating knee pain。 Geronimo， thirty-six years old， has liver failure， but his meager disability check disqualifies him for Medicaid—and puts a life-saving transplant just out of reach。 Roxana， who’s lived in the community without a visa for more than two decades， suffers from complications related to her cancer treatment。 And finally， there’s Ebonie， a young mother whose high-risk pregnancy endangers her life。 Whether due to immigration status， income， or the vagaries of state Medicaid law， all five are denied access to care。 For all five， this exclusion could prove life-threatening。
Each patient eventually lands at Ben Taub， the county hospital where Dr。 Nuila has worked for over a decade。 Nuila delves with empathy into the experiences of his patients， braiding their dramas into a singular narrative that contradicts the established idea that the only way to receive good healthcare is with good insurance。 As readers follow the movingly rendered twists and turns in each patient’s story， it’s impossible to deny that our system is broken—and that Ben Taub’s innovative model， which emphasizes people over payments， could help light the path forward。
Reviews
Libriar
，
4。5 stars。 Grounding the book with stories of several of his patients， Nuila looks at the United States health care system through how things work at Ben Taub hospital in Houston。 Ben Taub and the Gold Card system in Houston should serve as a model for health care in the rest of the country。 To see such good things happening in a red state gives me hope。 Anyone who does not believe in universal health care should have at least some of their beliefs changed after reading this moving book。 ARC cou 4。5 stars。 Grounding the book with stories of several of his patients， Nuila looks at the United States health care system through how things work at Ben Taub hospital in Houston。 Ben Taub and the Gold Card system in Houston should serve as a model for health care in the rest of the country。 To see such good things happening in a red state gives me hope。 Anyone who does not believe in universal health care should have at least some of their beliefs changed after reading this moving book。 ARC courtesy of the publisher and NetGalley。 。。。more
Kate Olson
，
（free review copy） Writing about healthcare in America means choosing who to write for。 Struggling citizens， the comfortably insured， healthcare workers， politicians ~ all have their own view of our healthcare systems and I believe that Nuila has managed to write a book that can serve them all。 As a healthcare consumer privileged enough to have insurance through my husband's union， I have long been aware that not all people in our country have the same access that I do， but I haven't always unde （free review copy） Writing about healthcare in America means choosing who to write for。 Struggling citizens， the comfortably insured， healthcare workers， politicians ~ all have their own view of our healthcare systems and I believe that Nuila has managed to write a book that can serve them all。 As a healthcare consumer privileged enough to have insurance through my husband's union， I have long been aware that not all people in our country have the same access that I do， but I haven't always understand the exact ramifications of that disparity。 Now I have a much clearer picture。 Through reading this work， politicians with open minds can understand the ramifications of their policies and healthcare workers can either relate or get a glimpse into a different side of the medical system than they are used to working in。 Struggling Americans will feel seen。This book is set at Ben Taub， a safety net hospital in Houston， Texas that operates in a unique fashion funded by local tax payers。 All are served， regardless of coverage status， but level of service still varies depending on citizenship status and coverage。 I loved reading about the purity of service that medical staff can achieve working in such a system versus a profit or traditional non-profit hospital and was touched by Nuila's dedication to this type of care。 As an educator I was struck by the parallels between staff at Ben Taub and teachers in public education who show up every day despite the massive structural issues because we care and we know we can help people。 The People's Hospital is written in a very accessible format， with stories of the author's family and own experiences woven in with accounts of several patients' journeys through the healthcare system and Ben Taub。 This is not a dense academic read， but one that combines stories and commentary on our nation's healthcare systems through the lens of a passionate practitioner。 Nuila doesn't have a solid answer for how we can fix our systems beyond Medicare for all with a 2nd tier option， but I believe that the book reads as an urgent call to action that anyone who has always had insurance must read to understand just how privileged we are。 How can you understand how to vote on healthcare issues if you don't understand how dire the situation is？ How can you be outraged about the inequality and massive overbilling and overspending if you don't know about them？ I learned so much about the Affordable Care Act， Medicaid and healthcare for people without citizenship that will allow me to advocate for change。A perfect follow-up to my recent read of Poverty， by America。Source: Edelweiss digital review copy 。。。more
Maria McGrath
，
Growing up in Houston， we drove by Ben Taub many a time， but I never really thought about what was gong on in there。 Thanks to Dr。 Nuila's nuanced portrayal， I now see what a beacon of hope it truly is， and， more than hope， how it gives dignity back to the critically ill。 The reader feels as though they discover， along with Nulia， the ways that our broken health and welfare systems lead directly to dire outcomes and how one's wealth and social standing cannot be overlooked when prognoses and dia Growing up in Houston， we drove by Ben Taub many a time， but I never really thought about what was gong on in there。 Thanks to Dr。 Nuila's nuanced portrayal， I now see what a beacon of hope it truly is， and， more than hope， how it gives dignity back to the critically ill。 The reader feels as though they discover， along with Nulia， the ways that our broken health and welfare systems lead directly to dire outcomes and how one's wealth and social standing cannot be overlooked when prognoses and diagnoses are made。 Nulia's book was clear， immediate， and intimate， and I also appreciated the stories of his own family interactions from his loving， but burnt-out doctor father to the various cousins who couldn't trust his advice about his own grandmother。 Anyone who has enjoyed books by Atul Gawande or Siddhartha Mukherjee should add this to their list of well-written， absorbing， and informative medical nonfiction。 。。。more
Feathered Quill Book Reviews
，
Dr。 Ricardo Nuila， an internal medicine doctor and hospitalist at Ben Taub Hospital in Houston， Texas， is tired。 Admittedly， Nuila does not explicitly say he is tired in his new book The People’s Hospital: Hope and Peril in American Medicine; however， one gets the sense， based on his written assault against what he calls “Medicine Inc。，” he is exhausted with the politics， bureaucracy， and capitalization of the United States healthcare industrial complex。 This book， which is sometimes repetitive Dr。 Ricardo Nuila， an internal medicine doctor and hospitalist at Ben Taub Hospital in Houston， Texas， is tired。 Admittedly， Nuila does not explicitly say he is tired in his new book The People’s Hospital: Hope and Peril in American Medicine; however， one gets the sense， based on his written assault against what he calls “Medicine Inc。，” he is exhausted with the politics， bureaucracy， and capitalization of the United States healthcare industrial complex。 This book， which is sometimes repetitive but always engaging， exposes what Nuila sees as a uniquely American issue that needs serious attention from federal and state legislators down to the lowliest of patients， the ones who truly suffer and sometimes perish because of rising costs， lower standards， and uncaring corporate interests。What Nuila claims throughout The People’s Hospital is healthcare workers need to provide “good care” to the sick and dying despite what is happening in Washington D。C。 or in our nation’s Capital buildings， and he defines “good care” as simple human connectedness。 He claims Ben Taub Hospital， a safety-net facility that mercifully takes in undocumented immigrants， the indigent， and the uninsured， succeeds in still providing “good care” because they are not as beholden to “Medicine Inc。” as for-profit hospitals are around the country。 Nuila attempts to prove his argument by telling the traumatic stories of several of his patients throughout the years， all of whom had caring experiences not only at Ben Taub Hospital but in Texas’s Harris Health System。 These individuals become examples and， on some levels， the focal point of Nuila’s book。 Indeed， it is easy for the author to get lost in the industry’s noise by writing a 300-page diatribe， but our fair doctor does not fall into that trap; he does not give in to the temptation of giving the corporations more page-time than they deserve。 He consciously places his subjects to the fore in an attempt to humanize humans who sometimes are identified more for their ailments and their ability to pay rather than for who they are as a mother， father， brother， sister， friend， etc。In essence， Nuila is a humanist and a storyteller who practices medicine。 In his book， readers are exposed to several severely-ill patients whom he had encounters with， all of them considered high-risk because of their afflictions and their problematic life/economic situations （a good portion of them were uninsured or relied on federal and state healthcare）: Stephen， who has tonsil cancer; Roxana， who had gangrene and tumors; and， Ebonie， who had a high-risk pregnancy that resulted in massive blood loss， are those he starts with （later he provides more stories）。 It is in these moments where he successfully mixes their health issues with what is happening administratively and financially to them， specifically， being representations of how the system treats the infirmed: without the aid coming from a variety of sources， including empathic and charitable private donors， none of these three human beings would have survived。 Nuila’s use of reliable resources from places like the New England Journal of Medicine， along with his expertise and his comprehensive examples， provides an in-depth understanding of what is medically happening in the United States， something many private and public doctors do not want to see happen to their patients。 At the same time， he speaks about his own familial history， which includes a doctor-for-a-father who started his practice caring for his patients but unfortunately was forced to become a bureaucrat focused on where the money was coming from。 The content itself works in this book on multiple levels; however， sometimes the flow of the book， although intentional， needs more of a written rationale to help readers follow his logic， especially because of the multitude of “characters” we are exposed to。Ultimately， The People’s Hospital is a realistic look at medicine as business and political beachball， while we， as patients or potential patients， become numb to the exorbitant amounts of money we pay to ensure we survive。 He is trying to wake readers up to what is happening in the United States as it pertains to our healthcare。 The question is: Do we care enough to listen？Quill says: Although organizationally confusing， The People’s Hospital significantly exposes “Medicine Inc。” as heartlessly capitalizing on those who need both treatment and compassion。 。。。more
Caitlin Fry
，
"Wow" was probably the most common word I spoke aloud while reading this book — sometimes in wonder， sometimes in shock， and sometimes in despair。 I am incredibly impressed that Dr。 Nuila wrote this book on top of his other commitments， but I am so thankful that he did。 More people need to spend time assessing and understanding the complexity that is our healthcare system as well as the people who not only use it but also work in it。 As not many people may pick this book up as a "fun read" in th "Wow" was probably the most common word I spoke aloud while reading this book — sometimes in wonder， sometimes in shock， and sometimes in despair。 I am incredibly impressed that Dr。 Nuila wrote this book on top of his other commitments， but I am so thankful that he did。 More people need to spend time assessing and understanding the complexity that is our healthcare system as well as the people who not only use it but also work in it。 As not many people may pick this book up as a "fun read" in their bookstore， I am very hopeful that it is picked up by media outlets and educational institutions （high school to pre-med） so discussions can be held as that is the awareness that will spread into gen。 pop and hopefully bleed into our voting decisions。 *Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC。 。。。more
Elyssa
，
A book that centers around what happens when someone can't afford American healthcare。 Nulia has done his research and packs this full of data and humanity。 A book that centers around what happens when someone can't afford American healthcare。 Nulia has done his research and packs this full of data and humanity。 。。。more
Winna Pham
，
Firstly， thank you NetGalley for gifting me this for an advanced reading！ As a dentist who works in a rural community health center and who is also living in a Republican state， this book spoke to so many experiences I've had。 The stories included are both inspiring and realistic; each patient description is gut wrenching， complex， and true to life。 My favorite parts of the book are the author's descriptions of how the failures in America's insurance system leads to burn out and shortage of heal Firstly， thank you NetGalley for gifting me this for an advanced reading！ As a dentist who works in a rural community health center and who is also living in a Republican state， this book spoke to so many experiences I've had。 The stories included are both inspiring and realistic; each patient description is gut wrenching， complex， and true to life。 My favorite parts of the book are the author's descriptions of how the failures in America's insurance system leads to burn out and shortage of healthcare personnel。 My biggest criticism is that I think this book suffers from a lack of editing。 There are parts in the first half of the book that feel disorganized and， at times， disconnected。 It jumps from story to story often， and I found myself trying to understand how each story fit into the subject of the chapter I was on。 While I do think that the last third of the book makes it a worthwhile read， I also kept going because I was given this as an ARC。 I might have put it down and not returned to it otherwise。 Unlike the author， I grew up with government insurance and used "safety net" options in healthcare。 While I think some of the book's strongest points are when the author describes his passion in caring for his patients， another criticism I have is that I wish he had stated more outright how privileged he was to be standing on the other side of the system as the son of a doctor and the one giving the care rather than needing the care。 There were times when I was unsure who the audience for this book was meant to be and whether the general public would have anything to gain from reading this。 From the author's tone， it seemed to me that he was often describing his shock in how many people experience such difficult situations in healthcare。 But for the majority of Americans， this is just a fact of life。 This book seems more like a call to action for hospital administration and government officials who are disconnected from the day-to-day realities of healthcare than for the average person and consumer。Overall， I'm glad that I read it。 I would say that this is more of a 3，5 star read than a 4 star， but I'm rounding up because I think it would be a worthwhile read for the right person。 。。。more
Morgan
，
The People's Hospital balances telling what's wrong with our healthcare system while telling the stories of patients in a sensitive way。 As someone who knew little about Ben Taub hospital， it was very interesting to hear Ricardo Nuila's perspective about it。 Overall I was really impressed that this was Nuila's debut book， the writing style really reminded me of Evicted by Matthew Desmond。 Thank you to NetGalley and Scribner for this review copy。 The People's Hospital balances telling what's wrong with our healthcare system while telling the stories of patients in a sensitive way。 As someone who knew little about Ben Taub hospital， it was very interesting to hear Ricardo Nuila's perspective about it。 Overall I was really impressed that this was Nuila's debut book， the writing style really reminded me of Evicted by Matthew Desmond。 Thank you to NetGalley and Scribner for this review copy。 。。。more
Jen Juenke
，
After reading the book: IF I Betray These Words about moral injury that doctors face， it was time to read something hopeful in healthcare。The author， who is a doctor， wrote this book to describe how messed the American Healthcare system is。I applauded his efforts to humanize the faces of what healthcare for all could be like。 I also appreciated his delivery of why things were so bad in healthcare。 One of the downsides was that I really got involved in the patients lives that he chronicled。 I nee After reading the book: IF I Betray These Words about moral injury that doctors face， it was time to read something hopeful in healthcare。The author， who is a doctor， wrote this book to describe how messed the American Healthcare system is。I applauded his efforts to humanize the faces of what healthcare for all could be like。 I also appreciated his delivery of why things were so bad in healthcare。 One of the downsides was that I really got involved in the patients lives that he chronicled。 I needed to know what happened to Ebonie's premature baby。 What happened to Steve？ Did his tonsil cancer come back？Overall its a great book to see how health care CAN and more importantly SHOULD be run。 Anyone who is interested in healthcare in America should read this book。 Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for this ARC in exchange for this honest review。 。。。more
Michelle
，
Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for this review copy。I love medical memoirs， and I was really looking forward to this。 It didn't meet my expectations--it blew them away。 This is a medical memoir。 Sensitively told stories of patients。 AND an amazing examination of American medicine， what has gone wrong， and some ideas on how to fix it。 All told with patience and empathy。 This book is constructed beautifully and is already on my top ten list for 2023。 Just such a good book。 I love that there Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for this review copy。I love medical memoirs， and I was really looking forward to this。 It didn't meet my expectations--it blew them away。 This is a medical memoir。 Sensitively told stories of patients。 AND an amazing examination of American medicine， what has gone wrong， and some ideas on how to fix it。 All told with patience and empathy。 This book is constructed beautifully and is already on my top ten list for 2023。 Just such a good book。 I love that there are institutions like Ben Taub in Houston and I just wish all Americans had access to something like this， and I think Dr。 Nuila's ideas can be used to help the spiraling costs of medical care while improving it at the same time。 Highly recommended。 。。。more
Cornmaven
，
Many thanks to Scribner for the digital ARC received。 Excellent journey through the American medicine landscape through the eyes of Nuila， a hospitalist at Ben Taub Hospital in Houston， one of two public/county hospitals who serve the area。 Nuila uses several patients' cases to illustrate the brokenness of our system， and how people get sicker as they try to navigate it。 He also brings readers up to date on the history of medical care in the US since WWII， when we decided not to do universal hea Many thanks to Scribner for the digital ARC received。 Excellent journey through the American medicine landscape through the eyes of Nuila， a hospitalist at Ben Taub Hospital in Houston， one of two public/county hospitals who serve the area。 Nuila uses several patients' cases to illustrate the brokenness of our system， and how people get sicker as they try to navigate it。 He also brings readers up to date on the history of medical care in the US since WWII， when we decided not to do universal healthcare and chose a capitalist profit based system。 He makes a great case for the lower costs of single payer healthcare， as evidenced by how Ben Taub operates。 I found it both fascinating and disheartening， as the will to change does not exist in our country yet。 The patients' stories were heroic。 。。。more
Marika
，
Where do people who need medical care go for help if they have no insurance or who are underinsured？ This debut work by Dr。 Ricardo Nuila is both fascinating and enraging at the same time。 Many Americans are routinely turned away from the facilities and offices that they most need when they are sick or hurt。 The same facilities that are created for the sick。 Why？ Because there is the catch that one must have the *correct* insurance in order to secure the treatment。 Readers will read about Stephe Where do people who need medical care go for help if they have no insurance or who are underinsured？ This debut work by Dr。 Ricardo Nuila is both fascinating and enraging at the same time。 Many Americans are routinely turned away from the facilities and offices that they most need when they are sick or hurt。 The same facilities that are created for the sick。 Why？ Because there is the catch that one must have the *correct* insurance in order to secure the treatment。 Readers will read about Stephen， a dedicated， hard worker who signed up for his company’s lowest priced plan thinking that it was sufficient only to be diagnosed with cancer which virtually bankrupted him。 The author skillfully and compassionately follows Stephen and four other people who are caught up in the whirlpool of healthcare at Ben Taub， a County hospital in Houston， Texas。 Author Nuila does a superb job of highlighting the greed that is infecting the medical care system and insurance companies while giving hope that there are those in the healthcare field that truly care。 Perfect for book clubs。*I read an advance copy and was not compensated。 。。。more
Jennifer Holloway Jones
，
I felt that this book shed some light on our broken health care system and ways that the Ben Taub hospital has found to work around this。 I truly appreciated the unique perspective that this physician provides and that he has done a lot of research to be able to demonstrate the statistics and data as well。 Thanks for the ARC， NetGalley。
WickedReads221b
，
Thanks NetGalley for the ARC。 This book is long， but worth it。 As someone who works in healthcare/ patient care this book gives me much hope for the future of our VERY broken healthcare system。。
Alex
，
Received free copy from publisher， in advance of publication。 Wow！ I really enjoyed this。 I don’t say this lightly as I’ve worked as a medical social worker for 20 years and like to think I’m familiar with most things social justice。 But the Ben Taub system is new。 Author did a great job developing patient stories which highlight the benefits of paradigm。 And yes he also explains limitations but in context of cost savings， ethical considerations and overall good to society。 Highly recommend。
Katie Bake
，
I work in healthcare in Houston， so reading this was a very personal experience for me。 The way Dr。 Nuila describes the system that patients in Ben Taub hospital must navigate while all being significantly and chronically ill is what I see on a daily basis in a similar hospital in the Houston suburbs。 My hospital also being a safety-net hospital for the area， really allowed me to make appropriate parallels to the stories of these patients。 This book should be required reading for residents who w I work in healthcare in Houston， so reading this was a very personal experience for me。 The way Dr。 Nuila describes the system that patients in Ben Taub hospital must navigate while all being significantly and chronically ill is what I see on a daily basis in a similar hospital in the Houston suburbs。 My hospital also being a safety-net hospital for the area， really allowed me to make appropriate parallels to the stories of these patients。 This book should be required reading for residents who will be working in hospitals such as Ben Taub， not only does it do a delicate job of explaining how the system works， but it gives careful， and thoughtful consideration to the needs of the patients， the government and how things got to where they are。 The writing is appropriate for people who have no medical background， or who have only stepped foot in a hospital for births， or broken bones。 The ability to explain in such detail while also keeping in mind that most people don't understand medical terminology， diagnosis， or lab results is a gift not many physicians have。 I will be recommending this book to the physicians I work with。 This is the most personable story of a physician in a broken system that I have ever read。 Thank you to Dr。 Nuila for the opportunity to learn。 。。。more
tpg0
，
As an AI language model， I don't have personal opinions or feelings， but I can provide an overview of the book "The People's Hospital: Hope and Peril in American Medicine。" Written by David Ansell， "The People's Hospital" is an insightful exploration of the state of healthcare in America。 It follows the stories of the author's experiences as a doctor in Cook County Hospital， a public hospital in Chicago that provided healthcare to the indigent population。 The book delves into how healthcare policy intersects with race， class， and the overall socioeconomic status of Americans。 Through patient stories， the author presents the harsh realities faced by those who cannot afford good healthcare。 The book also highlights the ways in which hospitals attempt to make up for funding shortfalls and the difficulties they face in doing so。 Overall， "The People's Hospital" presents a compelling argument for the need to reform our healthcare system， grounded in the author's extensive experience as both a physician and a patient。
tpg1
，
As an AI language model， I cannot provide a personal opinion or review about a book。 However， 'The People's Hospital: Hope and Peril in American Medicine' is a non-fiction book by David Barton Smith that explores the history， politics， and challenges facing American hospitals。 The book illuminates the complexities of healthcare policy， the role of healthcare industries， and the disparities in access to healthcare services。 It is a well-researched and comprehensive analysis of the state of American healthcare and an insightful examination of the people who are affected by the system。
tpg2
，
As an AI language model， I do not have opinions。 However， I can give you an overview of the book 'The People's Hospital: Hope and Peril in American Medicine。' 'The People's Hospital' is a book written by David Ansell， an experienced physician who has spent most of his career working with underserved communities。 In the book， Ansell explores the history of Cook County Hospital in Chicago， which has been serving the city's poor and uninsured for over 150 years。 Ansell gives a detailed account of how the hospital has transformed over the years， from a place of last resort for the destitute to a world-renowned institution that provides cutting-edge medical care。 However， he also highlights the challenges the hospital has faced over the years， including systemic racism， underfunding， and political opposition。 Ansell argues that Cook County Hospital represents a microcosm of the broader challenges facing American healthcare。 He also uses the hospital's history to demonstrate the importance of fighting for public healthcare as a fundamental right for all Americans。 Overall， 'The People's Hospital' is a thought-provoking and insightful book that sheds light on some of the most significant issues facing American healthcare today。
Tag
-
the peoples map of global china patients中文 peoples people’s bank of china