Gangsters of Capitalism: Smedley Butler, the Marines, and the Making and Breaking of America's Empire

Gangsters of Capitalism: Smedley Butler, the Marines, and the Making and Breaking of America's Empire

  • Downloads:3977
  • Type:Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
  • Create Date:2022-01-03 00:19:37
  • Update Date:2025-09-06
  • Status:finish
  • Author:Jonathan M. Katz
  • ISBN:1250135583
  • Environment:PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle

Summary

A groundbreaking journey tracing America’s forgotten path to global powerand how its legacies shape our world todaytold through the extraordinary life of a complicated Marine。

Smedley Butler was the most celebrated warfighter of his time。 Bestselling books were written about him。 Hollywood adored him。 Wherever the flag went, “The Fighting Quaker” went—serving in nearly every major overseas conflict from the Spanish War of 1898 until the eve of World War II。 From his first days as a 16-year-old recruit at the newly seized Guantánamo Bay, he blazed a path for empire: helping annex the Philippines and the land for the Panama Canal, leading troops in China (twice), and helping invade and occupy Nicaragua, Puerto Rico, Haiti, Mexico, and more。 Yet in retirement, Butler turned into a warrior against war, imperialism, and big business, declaring: “I was a racketeer for capitalism。"


Award-winning author Jonathan Myerson Katz traveled across the world—from China to Guantánamo, the mountains of Haiti to the Panama Canal—and pored over the personal letters of Butler, his fellow Marines, and his Quaker family on Philadelphia's Main Line。 Along the way, Katz shows how the consequences of the Marines' actions are still very much alive: talking politics with a Sandinista commander in Nicaragua, getting a martial arts lesson from a devotee of the Boxer Rebellion in China, and getting cast as a P。O。W。 extra in a Filipino movie about their American War。 Tracing a path from the first wave of U。S。 overseas expansionism to the rise of fascism in the 1930s to the crises of democracy in our own time, Gangsters of Capitalism tells an urgent story about a formative era most Americans have never learned about, but that the rest of the world cannot forget。

Download

Reviews

Paula

Review Rollingstone。com 1Jan 2022

Ginette

I was excited to have won an Advance Reader Copy of this book。 While living in North America now, I grew up in Europe where my schooling took place。 I loved the opportunity to learn more about US history, outside of its borders, through following the career of Smedley Butler from the late 1800's to the start of WWII。 The book is meticulously researched and makes for easy reading in spite of the idea that, perhaps such content may be somewhat dry。 At times, I had to remind myself I was not readin I was excited to have won an Advance Reader Copy of this book。 While living in North America now, I grew up in Europe where my schooling took place。 I loved the opportunity to learn more about US history, outside of its borders, through following the career of Smedley Butler from the late 1800's to the start of WWII。 The book is meticulously researched and makes for easy reading in spite of the idea that, perhaps such content may be somewhat dry。 At times, I had to remind myself I was not reading fiction with a fast paced story taking me to different places in the world, but rather facts of history。 Very small point: I would have loved for the book to have included an illustrated map of the time, showing the places of US military action (just me being a lover of maps)。 The author's emotion in its telling comes through in many instances。 Looking through the lens of today's values, there is no denying the racism, violence and greed of those times, with (a lot) more progress to be made in today's world。 Smedley, likewise, decided war and greed are not the answer and spoke out against it in later years。 The author reflects in the epilogue: who knows what comes next will be better or worse。 Let's hope for the better。 。。。more

Randal White

I was very surprised by this book。 I thought that I was quite well read in the history of American foreign policy, but thanks to this book, I now realize that I was subjected to quite a biased education of it。 You know, the "you-rah-rah" America that we were all taught in school。 How the U。S。 was a force of good, bringing freedom to those places that needed it。 Katz opened my eyes to a different perspective。 That of the U。S。 as an imperialistic force, out to further the advances of big businesse I was very surprised by this book。 I thought that I was quite well read in the history of American foreign policy, but thanks to this book, I now realize that I was subjected to quite a biased education of it。 You know, the "you-rah-rah" America that we were all taught in school。 How the U。S。 was a force of good, bringing freedom to those places that needed it。 Katz opened my eyes to a different perspective。 That of the U。S。 as an imperialistic force, out to further the advances of big businesses and the rich。 He does this through the eyes of a famous U。S。 Marine, Smedley Butler。 Raised as a Quaker, he somehow finds himself enlisted in the Marine Corps。 And on to his adventures! Beginning as a tough, literally take no prisoners hellhound, he is sent to the Philippines, Cuba, Nicaragua, Haiti, China, and Panama。 As he "grows", he discovers that the reasons are not just to promote the freedom-loving ways of the U。S。, but to benefit the rich。 He grows more and more disillusioned to the fighting and killing。 Finally retiring, he finds himself being recruited into a plot to overthrow the Federal Government。 To which, to his great credit, he exposes。 On a personal level, I really enjoyed the sections on China。 My grandfather was in the Navy there at the same time, and now I think I have a feeling about what we went through, and why he would never talk about it。 Also, regarding the ending, with the plot to overthrow the government; I could not help but draw parallels with the machinations of the Trump administration after the 2020 election (and continuing to today)。 This is a long, and sometimes tiring book。 But it is never boring。 I really think that if you read it, you will come away with a much greater sense of our place in history。 And why we have some of the problems we have today。 And why some nations do not trust us。 Very educational! 。。。more

Ron Frampton

Tracing AMERICA'S path to global power and how it shaped our world today。 Tracing AMERICA'S path to global power and how it shaped our world today。 。。。more

Sean

I received an advance copy of this book through a goodreads giveaway。 The book was excellent and I highly recommend it for anyone who wants a concise history of US interventionism and the covering up of inconvenient information。 It is very well-researched, with sources for almost every claim, including some interesting historical asides in the footnotes。 My only critique ends up also being the book's greatest asset; that Katz sometimes takes liberty with the description of action in certain poin I received an advance copy of this book through a goodreads giveaway。 The book was excellent and I highly recommend it for anyone who wants a concise history of US interventionism and the covering up of inconvenient information。 It is very well-researched, with sources for almost every claim, including some interesting historical asides in the footnotes。 My only critique ends up also being the book's greatest asset; that Katz sometimes takes liberty with the description of action in certain points of Butler's life, making scenes from the past come to life, but in some cases the description of the action isn't cited from one of Butler'sletters, it's not clear how much is historical and how much is embellishment describing how a scene might have occurred。 With the narrative and reportage style of writing (similar to some books by Erik Larson, but not as dry), the book is an excellent introduction to the rise of the American empire and how the world has been influenced by it。 I especially liked the fact that Katz switches between a view of the past through Butler's eyes (often as the leader of an invading force), and then his own experience in those countries years later while doing research for this book。 Seeing how other countries remember and continue to remember the US invasions is a powerful reminder that these events are not over and done with as many Americans would like to think。 As well as the fact that he relied as much (if not more) on historians from the countries Butler traveled to as historians from the US to tell the story。The book is as much about American interventionism as it is a critical review about how the US (and other countries) teaches history and how that teaching can define common enemies while completely erasing others for the benefit of the wealthiest and most influential leaders。 。。。more

William Harris

I leave my perusal of Jonathan M。 Katz's "Gangsters of Capitalism" (kindly provided to me by St。 Martin's Press in the form of an ARC) with very mixed feelings but resolved not, myself, to fall into some of the traps that the author falls into。 The problem, such as it is, revolves around the strong idealogical bias with which the author infuses this work and his own analyses of events in the life of his protagonist, General Smedley Butler, one of the most famous Marines in the history of the Uni I leave my perusal of Jonathan M。 Katz's "Gangsters of Capitalism" (kindly provided to me by St。 Martin's Press in the form of an ARC) with very mixed feelings but resolved not, myself, to fall into some of the traps that the author falls into。 The problem, such as it is, revolves around the strong idealogical bias with which the author infuses this work and his own analyses of events in the life of his protagonist, General Smedley Butler, one of the most famous Marines in the history of the United States Marine Corps。 My quandary, as a reviewer, is that the author's ideological stance is directly contrary to my own position, and this makes it more difficult for me to be as fair as I want to be。 At the risk of oversimplifying, I suspect Mr。 Katz would identify his own political (and polemical position) as what has come to be called Progressivism (in the modern far left sense) while my approach is essentially Libertarian。 With that out of the way, I should point out that, as a primer on the growth of imperial diplomacy as practiced by the United States, the book is quite useful。 General Butler and his policies and beliefs loom large in any study of the growth of the American Empire following the Spanish-American War。 He was involved in the Philippine Islands, Cuba, Nicaragua, Haiti, China, and Panama (as well as sundry other places, including a stint as Philadelphia Chief of Police at the beginning of Prohibition)! The narrative focuses on Butler and his exploits, usually recounted in an entertaining anecdotal fashion and only strays most obviously from this when the author jumps forward in time to his own experiences in some of the places that were shaped by Butler and his men。 Throughout, the author maintains a consistent position towards the events he is describing。 The text, despite my disappointment with the overarching perspective, is both informative and revealing, and I would recommend it to anyone trying to discover the roots of our modern difficulties in a number of places, but most especially in Mexico and Central America。 There is much to be learned here despite my reservations。 。。。more