Looking for the Good War: American Amnesia and the Violent Pursuit of Happiness

Looking for the Good War: American Amnesia and the Violent Pursuit of Happiness

  • Downloads:1372
  • Type:Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
  • Create Date:2021-12-28 00:19:14
  • Update Date:2025-09-06
  • Status:finish
  • Author:Elizabeth D. Samet
  • ISBN:B08R2L7VH9
  • Environment:PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle

Summary

A wide-ranging work of cultural history and criticism that reexamines the impact of post–World War II myths of the “good war"

In Looking for the Good War, Elizabeth D。 Samet reexamines the literature, art, and culture that emerged after World War II, bringing her expertise as a professor of English at West Point to bear on the complexity of the postwar period in national life。 She exposes the confusion about American identity that was expressed during and immediately after the war, and the deep national ambivalence toward war, violence, and veterans—all of which were suppressed in subsequent decades by a dangerously sentimental attitude toward the United States’ “exceptional” history and destiny。 Ranging across film and literature, she finds the war's ambivalent legacy in some of its most heavily mythologized figures: the war correspondent epitomized by Ernie Pyle; the character of the erstwhile G。I。 turned either cop or criminal in the pulp fiction and feature films of the late 1940s; the disaffected Civil War veteran who looms so large on the screen in the Cold War Western; and the resurgent military hero of the post-Vietnam period。 Taken together, these figures reveal key elements of postwar attitudes toward violence, liberty, and nation—attitudes that have shaped domestic and foreign policy and that respond in various ways to various assumptions about national identity and purpose established or affirmed by World War II。

As the United States reassesses its roles in Afghanistan and the Middle East, the time has come to rethink our national mythology: the way that World War II shaped our sense of national destiny, our attitudes toward the use of American military force throughout the world, and our inability to accept the realities of the twenty-first century’s decades of devastating conflict。

Download

Reviews

Ronnie

oh boy! This is the kind of book that is boosted and held up by other books she mentions。 The subject is War。 God。 Good bad or indifferent。 the concepts of citizen/soldier or soldier/citizen。 That particular concept hawhawed me because I was punished in Basic Training for speaking out to my drill sergeant that I was a citizen first and soldier second。 He made me do push-ups until I was physically exhausted。 He then proceeded to ask me if a I seen the error of my ways。 I said no。 I am a citizen f oh boy! This is the kind of book that is boosted and held up by other books she mentions。 The subject is War。 God。 Good bad or indifferent。 the concepts of citizen/soldier or soldier/citizen。 That particular concept hawhawed me because I was punished in Basic Training for speaking out to my drill sergeant that I was a citizen first and soldier second。 He made me do push-ups until I was physically exhausted。 He then proceeded to ask me if a I seen the error of my ways。 I said no。 I am a citizen first soldier second。 He now made me do pushups again。 The rest of my unit marched smartly to the barracks。 I couldn't do anymore。 My arms and body were meshed into the ground。。 My face in the dirt。 The drill sergeant finally came out to get me。 Again he asked me the question and I gave him the same answer。 He went ballistic。 Asked me where I came from。 When I told him where I was from。。。。he shouted that it figures。 I stayed laying down for at least two hours。 The platoon leader came to get me and told me I was on his shit list。 I only found after I got out of the Army that this concept that I argued with has been an ongoing dispute for eons。 I just blurted it out。 War and all it stands for is a many splintered thing。 Blood。 Anger。Disputes。 Religious connotations 。Nothing is sacred。 Everything is on the table。 Memories of past wars infect the days of present with the prisms of future essence。 Deaths。。Casulaties。 Recriminations。 Ongoing angers。 no end in sight。 This is a deadly book。 I'll probably reread this book in the future。 。。。more

Eric Smith

A critic's job is a challenging one。 They are puzzle-assemblers without the box-top photo as a guide。 They have to cast their net wide to gather the pieces, then assemble the Jenga tower in a way that is both methodical and engaging during construction, for the reader, and revelatory at the conclusion。Ms。 Samet casts her net far and wide as she seeks to explain the American understanding of our participation in World War II that took hold in the popular culture around the time of the war's 50th A critic's job is a challenging one。 They are puzzle-assemblers without the box-top photo as a guide。 They have to cast their net wide to gather the pieces, then assemble the Jenga tower in a way that is both methodical and engaging during construction, for the reader, and revelatory at the conclusion。Ms。 Samet casts her net far and wide as she seeks to explain the American understanding of our participation in World War II that took hold in the popular culture around the time of the war's 50th anniversary。 She quotes authors from Pericles to Lincoln to President G。 H。W。 Bush。 She analyzes the popular culture in the post-war years to see what Americans thought of the war when the dust was still fresh。 She reaches back to the US Civil War to find the origins of legend-creation and then to NASCAR and the NFL to see its contemporary exploitation。 No stone is left unturned - John Ford westerns, Spielberg, Woodie Guthrie's guitar, Confederate monuments。Her tapestry is compelling - as a society we've created and embraced a view of the War that never was。 It's not historical, but a cultural desire。 It's the comfort food we want to eat, not the meat and potatoes reality of what was。Literary and cultural criticism depends on a light to show the shadow。 There must be a point before the counterpoint。 If this text has any weakness its the lack of attention paid to the raw material of mythology - yes, the country was not a monolithic supporter of patriotism, sacrifice, and war aims but it did put 15 million Americans in uniform, mobilize the economy in support of the war, and achieve a decisive victory。Her conclusion that we owe it to history, our grandparents, and ourselves to have a better, more nuanced understanding of the War is well constructed and compelling。 I look forward to exploring her sources in more detail to gain a better personal understanding。 。。。more

Zach Feig

This is an interesting book, and a good reminder that war is bad。 However, the style of the book is very different from what I expected。 Be warned that this book is more or less a literary media and film review of war related content from the post-war period。 The book itself doesn't really tell a story so much is summarize lots of other people's work。 Again the basic point that people felt ambivalent towards world war II and have since forgotten that they felt that way is valid。 But you could ge This is an interesting book, and a good reminder that war is bad。 However, the style of the book is very different from what I expected。 Be warned that this book is more or less a literary media and film review of war related content from the post-war period。 The book itself doesn't really tell a story so much is summarize lots of other people's work。 Again the basic point that people felt ambivalent towards world war II and have since forgotten that they felt that way is valid。 But you could get that from just reading slaughterhouse 5 or one of the many other books listed in this book's bibliography。 Unless your goal is to sound like you've read post-work content without actually having read it, this book is probably not what you're looking for。。。 。。。more

Kelly

Outstanding。 Blows away the clutter and sentimentality that pervades our understanding of history。 This is an eye-opening story of how we metabolize the past, and how the stories we tell ourselves deprive our forbears of their humanity。 Just remarkable。

Elizabeth

As seen in the New Yorker: https://www。newyorker。com/magazine/20。。。 As seen in the New Yorker: https://www。newyorker。com/magazine/20。。。 。。。more

Izzy

The theme of this book is presented in with a superabundance of proofs and common sense, and illustrated by movies of the past 75 years, recaps of multiple Richard and henry plays of Shakespear, as well as by an exhaustive bibliography。 She uses the willfull reinterpretationof our Civil War to free the blacks as a War Between the States about states rights as backdrop for the similarly oversimplified interpretation of the American participation inWW 2 as an enterprise inspired by altruism。 One c The theme of this book is presented in with a superabundance of proofs and common sense, and illustrated by movies of the past 75 years, recaps of multiple Richard and henry plays of Shakespear, as well as by an exhaustive bibliography。 She uses the willfull reinterpretationof our Civil War to free the blacks as a War Between the States about states rights as backdrop for the similarly oversimplified interpretation of the American participation inWW 2 as an enterprise inspired by altruism。 One can get lost in the weeds of the many movies and Shakespeare plays she cites, but the overarching message comes through quite clearly, that all wars are of very mixed motive, with no side having a lock on pure maliciousness or pure goodness in its motivation for participation。 I suppose a group of American Jews might want to see WW2 as the “Good War”, in preventing Hitler’s successes at extermination of the race in Europe from spreading to England and the Americas, but even fromthat perspective, our participation in the war was unable to save but a miniscule fraction of those Jews that came under Hitler’s minions military control。 。。。more

Gary Beauregard Bottomley

Trump is a danger to every value I hold dear。 Trump’s mythologizing of America’s past and longing for a returning to the days of George Wallace and making America great again is tied up in Tom Brokaw’s idiotic cartoon characterization of idealizing the American veterans of WW II as the ‘greatest generation’。 The author gets the idiocy that’s inherent in Tom Brokaw’s bromide, and how stupid it really is and she uses mostly a string of related textual intellectual historical anecdotes to make her Trump is a danger to every value I hold dear。 Trump’s mythologizing of America’s past and longing for a returning to the days of George Wallace and making America great again is tied up in Tom Brokaw’s idiotic cartoon characterization of idealizing the American veterans of WW II as the ‘greatest generation’。 The author gets the idiocy that’s inherent in Tom Brokaw’s bromide, and how stupid it really is and she uses mostly a string of related textual intellectual historical anecdotes to make her case by showing through movies, books and thinkers of the war era how we saw ourselves differently from how Brokaw’s nonsense said otherwise, and she makes the case, but, really, who amongst use didn’t realize that Brokaw was full of shit?The author walks away from her own narrative by focusing on the wrong points while not seeing the bigger picture for what it is, and as the last line in ‘The Man Who Shot Liberty Valence’ says, ‘when the legend becomes fact, print the legend’。 It’s the myth that predominates and the world makes that true even though the legend is garbage。 Trump has told multiple times the story about how in the Philippines the Muslim soldiers wouldn’t use bullets made with pig grease, and were deathly afraid of being put into pig carcasses。 It’s peak bizarre Trumpism and it’s straight out of the movie ‘Lives of the Bengal Lancers’ (this author never mentioned that movie)。 For Trump and his moron followers it doesn’t matter if it’s true, what matters is they are in on the game and they can feel superior to the ‘stupid Muslims’ and to them it could just be true。 The author ended the book by quoting the Trump sycophant, Matt Gaetz to the effect that the American First movement is a great thing and Trump is clearly an American Firster。 Just in case you are not familiar, the American First movement sprung from the KKK and were Nazi sympathizers before WW II and morphed into the nutty Birchers and anti-communist after the war。 The author did spend a lot of time discussing the movie ‘Best Years of Our Lives’ (1946) but did not mention the scene where the guy at the diner asked Homer Parish about his artificial hands and mentioned how America supported the wrong side in WW II。 That guy would have been an American Firster in 1946, one who would think Russian communist were worst than German Nazis, and today he would support Matt Gaetz and Trump。 In the very end of the book, the author mentioned how her Russian studies expert colleague asked ‘where was Russia’ in her book, the author replied that her book was about America。 That is a part of the problem with this book。 America made WW II the ‘last good war’ by forgetting Russia’s significance。 Antony Beevor wrote a book that is actually recommend by this author on WW II and our ethno-centric arrogance gets put in its place by the significance that Russia contributed to the war。 Beevor will mention that December 6, 1941 is more significant than the following day (Pearl Harbor Day), because Moscow mounted a counter-offensive against the Nazis and that was the beginning of the end of the Wehrmacht。 The author mentioned ‘The Hucksters’ and said that Clark Gable was a pilot。 I don’t think most people would have characterized his Army Air Corps career as a pilot, because he wasn’t。 She used that movie to illustrate the disillusionment of returning Vets。 You could say that, I guess, but I remember the great scene where Sidney Greenstreet spits a big old greenie on to the table and says ‘that’s disgusting, but you’ll remember that and that is what Madison Avenue is about, you remembering the product’。 Or, the author used the movie “A Lonely Place’ to illustrate the troubled returning vet, but what I remember is that Humphrey Bogart played against type a psychotic serial killer such that the woman in his life was flummoxed and was in denial until the end。 The author cited 100 or so movies which I’ve seen almost all of as she was making her points to feed into her narrative, but one could just as well as picked other movies and feed into the myth of the last good war, because, after all, the movies help make the myths we believe in as fact。 Trump uses the myths as facts and reenforces the exceptionalism his followers feel and tries to manipulate us。 He is a danger and that bigger story should have been told in this book, but the author kept walking from the bigger implications of her narrative。 BTW, I thought she did a good job on the Myth of the Lost Cause of the Civil War。 。。。more